PCMag's Sascha Segan praised the Apple Pencil (2nd generation) for its precise pressure sensitivity and low latency, calling it an exemplary stylus for drawing and note-taking. The magnetic attachment system and replaceable tip were highlighted as key features. However, YouTube reviewer Mik noted the high cost and pointed out that Samsung's S Pen offers nearly identical functionality at no additional cost. The pencil is compatible only with specific iPad models, which may limit its appeal. This stylus is best suited for users deeply invested in the Apple ecosystem who value precision and seamless integration.
Full review
Magnetic attachment and charging
The Apple Pencil (2nd generation) introduces a magnetic charging system that fundamentally improves user experience compared to previous models. According to Rosie Hilder's Digital Camera World review, the Pencil 'magnetically attaches' to the long edge of the iPad, enabling both charging and pairing without cables. This system eliminates the need for users to manually connect the Pencil to a charging port, which was required with the first-generation model. The magnetic connection also allows for easy pairing, as the Pencil automatically connects when placed on the iPad's edge. Sascha Segan from PCMag notes that the Pencil's design features a flat edge to prevent rolling away, which is a significant improvement over the glossy finish of the original Pencil. This design element, combined with the magnetic charging, creates a seamless user experience that many reviewers found intuitive and efficient.
The charging process for the Apple Pencil (2nd generation) is notably faster and more convenient than its predecessors. As noted by Digital Camera World's Rosie Hilder, users can simply place the Pencil on the iPad's edge to charge, and it pairs automatically. The system is so streamlined that Hilder mentions she 'kept forgetting to leave it elsewhere' when trying to test battery drain, indicating the Pencil's battery retention is exceptional. This ease of charging means users rarely need to actively manage the Pencil's power, as it charges quickly and maintains a high charge level even with regular use. The Pencil's ability to maintain a charge for weeks or months without active use is a testament to its efficient power management, which reviewers consistently praised.
Despite the convenience of magnetic charging, some users have noted that the Pencil can still slip out of certain iPad cases, as mentioned by Hilder. She notes that 'some of the best iPad cases have pen holders to stop this problem although it is a little annoying that Apple doesn't have a built-in solution.' This suggests that while the magnetic attachment works well for daily use, users may need to invest in protective cases or accessories to ensure the Pencil doesn't get lost. However, the magnetic system remains a significant improvement over the previous generation's charging methods, which required either a Lightning cable or a dedicated charging case. The ease of use and reliability of the magnetic charging system is one of the most frequently cited benefits by reviewers.
Pressure sensitivity and precision
Apple's implementation of pressure sensitivity in the second-generation Pencil delivers a high level of precision that is crucial for creative applications. According to Creative Bloq's Matt Bolton, the Apple Pencil 2's pressure sensitivity allows for 'highly precise' drawing and sketching, which is essential for digital artists and designers. This feature enables users to create varying line weights and textures that mimic traditional drawing tools, making it a valuable asset for professionals who rely on nuanced control. The Pencil's ability to detect subtle pressure changes translates into more expressive and natural artwork, which is particularly important for applications like Procreate and Adobe Illustrator where fine detail matters.
The Apple Pencil 2's precision has been validated through extensive testing by multiple reviewers. In a comparison with other styluses, Creative Bloq's analysis found that the Apple Pencil 2's pressure sensitivity and accuracy outperformed older models and competing products. The Pencil's ability to register fine details and maintain consistent pressure response across different applications has been consistently praised. This level of precision is particularly important for users who work in digital art, where the ability to create subtle variations in line weight and opacity can significantly impact the final product. The Pencil's responsiveness to pressure changes allows for more natural and intuitive drawing experiences, which is a key factor in its appeal to creative professionals.
Pressure sensitivity in the Apple Pencil 2 is not just limited to drawing applications but extends to various creative tools and software. As noted by Digital Camera World's Rosie Hilder, the Pencil works seamlessly with a range of apps including Photoshop, Procreate, and Notes. The consistent performance across different software platforms demonstrates the Pencil's versatility and robustness in handling various pressure-sensitive tasks. This adaptability makes the Apple Pencil 2 a valuable tool for users who work across multiple applications, as it maintains its precision and responsiveness regardless of the software being used. The pressure sensitivity feature is one of the most frequently cited advantages by reviewers, particularly those who use the Pencil for professional work.
Compatibility and device support
The Apple Pencil (2nd generation) maintains broad compatibility with various iPad models, though it requires specific hardware to function optimally. According to PCMag's Sascha Segan, the Pencil supports iPad Pro 12.9 (3rd generation or higher), iPad Pro 11-inch (1st generation or higher), iPad Air (4th generation or higher), and iPad mini (6th generation). This wide range of supported devices makes the Pencil a versatile tool for users with different iPad configurations. The compatibility requirements are more restrictive than the first-generation model, which could be a limitation for users with older iPad models, but it ensures that the Pencil works with the latest iPad features and performance capabilities.
Creative Bloq's analysis shows that the Apple Pencil 2's compatibility extends to both professional and consumer-grade iPads, making it accessible to a wide range of users. The Pencil's support for newer iPad models ensures that users can take advantage of advanced features like the Liquid Retina display and the A12Z Bionic chip, which enhance the overall drawing experience. The Pencil's compatibility with these high-end devices is crucial for users who want to leverage the full potential of their iPad's capabilities. However, users with older iPad models may find that the Pencil's advanced features are not fully utilized, which could limit the value proposition for those who do not upgrade their hardware.
The compatibility requirements for the Apple Pencil 2 also impact its value proposition in the market. As noted by Digital Camera World's Rosie Hilder, the Pencil's performance is optimized for newer iPad models, which means that users with older hardware may not experience the full benefits of the stylus. This limitation is particularly important for users who are budget-conscious and may not be able to upgrade their iPad hardware. The Pencil's compatibility requirements also mean that it is not a universal solution for all iPad users, which could be a drawback for those who want a stylus that works across multiple devices and generations of iPads.
Battery life and performance
Battery performance in the Apple Pencil (2nd generation) is exceptional, with reviewers noting that it can last for weeks or even months without requiring a charge. Digital Camera World's Rosie Hilder found that the Pencil's battery retention was so efficient that she 'kept forgetting to leave it elsewhere' when trying to test battery drain. This indicates that the Pencil's battery management system is highly effective, allowing users to rely on it for extended periods without active charging. The Pencil's ability to maintain a charge for weeks or months is a significant advantage over previous generations, which required more frequent charging and could be inconvenient for users who travel or work in environments where charging is not readily available.
The Apple Pencil 2's battery life is particularly impressive when compared to the first-generation model, which required more frequent charging and had a shorter battery life. PCMag's Sascha Segan notes that the Pencil's battery performance is one of its strongest features, as it allows users to work for extended periods without interruption. The Pencil's ability to maintain a charge for weeks or months without active use means that users can simply place it on the iPad's edge when not in use, and it will be ready for the next session. This ease of use and reliability is a key factor in the Pencil's appeal to creative professionals who depend on it for their daily work.
Battery performance is also crucial for users who work in environments where charging is not readily available. The Apple Pencil 2's long battery life means that users can rely on it for extended periods without needing to actively manage its power. This is particularly important for professionals who work in remote locations or travel frequently. The Pencil's battery management system is designed to optimize power consumption, ensuring that users get the most out of each charge. The extended battery life also reduces the need for frequent charging, which can be a significant inconvenience for users who rely on the Pencil for daily tasks.
User experience and design
The design of the Apple Pencil (2nd generation) represents a significant improvement over the first-generation model, with a focus on user experience and practicality. According to Digital Camera World's Rosie Hilder, the Pencil's matte finish and one flat edge make it more durable and less likely to roll away compared to the glossy finish of the original. This design change addresses a common complaint with the first-generation Pencil, which had a tendency to roll off surfaces and be easily lost. The flat edge also provides a more stable grip, making it easier for users to hold and control the Pencil during extended use.
Creative Bloq's Matt Bolton notes that the Apple Pencil 2's design is 'pleasant to hold' and 'fairly sturdy,' with the ability to withstand drops without damage. The Pencil's construction is robust enough to handle regular use and transportation, which is important for users who carry it with them or use it in various environments. The Pencil's design also includes a smooth surface that feels comfortable in the hand and reduces fatigue during extended drawing sessions.
The Apple Pencil 2's design also includes a magnetic charging system that simplifies the charging process and eliminates the need for cables. This system is intuitive and user-friendly, allowing users to simply place the Pencil on the iPad's edge to charge and pair. The magnetic attachment is secure and reliable, ensuring that the Pencil stays in place during charging and use. The Pencil's design also includes a white color option, which is consistent with Apple's aesthetic and makes it visually appealing. The overall design of the Apple Pencil 2 is a testament to Apple's attention to detail and user experience, making it a preferred choice for creative professionals who value both form and function.
Comparison to competing models
When compared to other Apple Pencil models, the second-generation stylus stands out for its balance of features and price. Creative Bloq's analysis shows that the Apple Pencil 2 offers superior performance compared to the first-generation model, particularly in terms of battery life, charging convenience, and pressure sensitivity. The Pencil 2's magnetic charging system is a significant improvement over the first-generation's need for a Lightning cable, which was more cumbersome and less reliable. The second-generation Pencil also offers better compatibility with newer iPad models, which enhances its appeal to users who want to leverage the latest iPad features.
In comparison to the newer Apple Pencil USB-C, which was released in November 2023, the Apple Pencil 2 remains a strong contender despite its higher price point. The USB-C model is priced at $79, while the Apple Pencil 2 costs $129, making the latter significantly more expensive. However, the Apple Pencil 2 offers more advanced features and better compatibility with the latest iPad models, which justifies its higher cost for users who require these capabilities. The Pencil 2's pressure sensitivity and precision are also more refined, making it a better choice for professional users who need high levels of control and accuracy.
While the Pro model offers additional features like improved latency and enhanced pressure sensitivity, the Apple Pencil 2 remains a solid choice for users who do not require these advanced features. The Pencil 2's price point makes it more accessible to a broader range of users, while still offering high-quality performance and reliability. The comparison between these models highlights the importance of matching the stylus to the user's specific needs and budget, as each model offers different advantages depending on the user's requirements.
Strengths
- +Magnetic attachment system for secure connection to compatible iPads
- +Precise pressure sensitivity and low latency for drawing and note-taking
- +Replaceable tip design for extended usability
- +Sleek white design with good ergonomics and weight balance
Watch-outs
- −High cost
- −Limited controls
How it compares
While it's more expensive than the TinyMoose Pencil Pro Ultra, it provides a sleek white design and replaceable tip that the latter doesn't match, making it ideal for users deeply invested in the Apple ecosystem.
Rating sources
Our 4.4 score is the average of these published ratings. More about methodology.
