Head-to-head · Best Instant Cameras

Polaroid I-2 vs Polaroid OneStep 2

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

The short answer

Polaroid OneStep 2 comes out ahead by a narrow margin (3.6 vs 3.9). The gap is mostly about traditional instant camera enthusiasts — read the strengths below before deciding.

Ranked #5 in Best Instant Cameras

Polaroid I-2

3.6

$64.99as of Jul 9

The Polaroid I-2 is a high-end instant camera featuring LiDAR autofocus, full manual controls, and compatibility with multiple Polaroid film types. Reviewed by Dan Bracaglia of DPReview, it combines modern camera technology with traditional design, offering a solid build quality and advanced features. However, YouTube reviewer experiences highlight issues with film counter malfunctions and jamming after extended use. This camera is ideal for advanced users seeking premium instant photography capabilities but may not suit those wanting a more basic or affordable option.

Strengths

— LiDAR autofocus system that works well in all lighting conditions including dim settings
— Full manual controls with aperture priority, shutter priority, and full manual modes
— Compatible with all Polaroid film types including i-Type, 600, and SX-70 film

Watch-outs

— Internal battery is not removable and rechargeable only via USB-C
— Shutter speed range limited to 30 sec to 1/250 sec with no bulb option
— Camera has reported issues with film counter malfunctioning and jamming

$64.99 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Higher ratedRanked #3 in Best Instant Cameras

Polaroid OneStep 2

3.9

The Polaroid OneStep 2 represents a modern revival of the classic instant camera format, featuring a built-in lithium battery that makes film packs cheaper and a bright built-in flash with override capability. Reviewers noted its good light meter performance and comfortable handling, though some found the lack of a viewfinder tube and the need to position the eye very close to the viewfinder to be annoying. The included strap is criticized as poor quality. This camera appeals to those seeking a traditional instant camera experience with modern conveniences, though users wanting a more refined viewfinder experience might look elsewhere.

Strengths

— Built-in lithium battery allows film packs to be cheaper as they no longer contain batteries
— Good built-in flash that is bright and has an override button
— Light meter performs well and rarely gets fooled

Watch-outs

— Missing viewfinder tube that helps guide the eye to the viewfinder
— Viewfinder requires putting eye very close which changes framing and can tilt the camera

Check Price on Amazon Full review →

How they stack up

Polaroid I-2

The Polaroid I-2's LiDAR autofocus and full manual controls make it superior to the Polaroid OneStep 2 and Snap 2, which lack advanced focusing capabilities. Unlike the Fujifilm Instax Square SQ40, it doesn't produce square prints but offers more professional features. Compared to the Lomo Instant Square, it lacks creative exposure modes but provides better image quality and more reliable operation.

Polaroid OneStep 2

The Polaroid OneStep 2 stands out with its built-in lithium battery that makes film packs cheaper, unlike the Polaroid I-2 which requires a removable internal battery. Compared to the Fujifilm Instax Square SQ40, it offers more traditional design elements and a better light meter, though it lacks the analog print delay feature. The Polaroid Snap 2's dual functionality and digital capture capabilities make it more versatile for creative users, but the OneStep 2 provides a more authentic instant camera experience.

Specs side-by-side

Spec	Polaroid I-2	Polaroid OneStep 2
Film Format	i-Type, 600, SX-70	i-Type and 600 type
Lens	98mm f/8	106mm plastic fixed
Flash	Built-in, with effective range 0 8.2 feet (0 2.5 meters)	Built-in with override button
Battery	Internal, USB-C rechargeable	Built-in lithium
Focusing	LiDAR	2 feet to infinity
Weight	1.2 lb (563 grams)	approx 460 grams

← See the full ranking of best instant cameras