The Schlage Encode Plus Smart WiFi Deadbolt offers exceptional compatibility with major smart home ecosystems, including Apple Home Key, while eliminating the need for a bridge via built-in Wi-Fi. Although the physical installation is straightforward and the device includes a physical key backup, users must download the Schlage Home app to manage it through Google or Alexa, and the unit is noted for being somewhat bulky. It is a solid choice for those prioritizing broad platform support and remote monitoring, despite the higher price point and lack of biometric sensors.
Full review
Universal Smart Home Compatibility
The defining feature of the Schlage Encode Plus is its unprecedented support for all major smart home ecosystems, a significant upgrade from the original Encode model. PCWorld reviewer Robert Strohmeyer highlighted that this lock bridges the gap between Amazon Alexa, Google Home, and Apple HomeKit, including support for Apple’s Home Key NFC technology. This means users can unlock the door with an iPhone or Apple Watch simply by bringing the device near the lock, a feature that Reviewed.com’s Rick Broida described as 'impressive' and 'cool.' Unlike many competitors that require a separate hub or bridge for connectivity, the Encode Plus features integrated Wi-Fi, allowing it to communicate directly with your home network. This eliminates the need for additional hardware like a Z-Wave controller, streamlining the setup process for users who want a plug-and-play experience without managing multiple smart home bridges.
Despite this broad compatibility, the integration is not entirely seamless across all platforms. PCWorld noted that while the lock works with all three major assistants, Google and Alexa users still need to use the Schlage Home app to manage certain settings, rather than having full control within their respective native apps. This creates a fragmented experience where Apple users enjoy a more native integration through HomeKit, while Android and Alexa users are tethered to the Schlage ecosystem for advanced configuration. However, for the average homeowner who simply wants voice control and remote access, the ability to use Siri, Alexa, or Google Assistant interchangeably is a major selling point. The lock’s versatility ensures that switching smart home platforms in the future does not require replacing the hardware, offering long-term flexibility that few other smart locks on the market can match.
Installation Experience and Ease of Use
Installation of the Schlage Encode Plus is generally praised for being straightforward, though experiences vary depending on the user’s DIY confidence. NYT Wirecutter’s Adrienne Maxwell, who initially felt intimidated by the prospect of installing a smart lock, found the process surprisingly simple thanks to the clearly labeled parts and detailed manual. She reported that the physical installation took minimal effort, with the only hiccup being a slightly crooked alignment that was easily corrected. Similarly, Reviewed.com’s Rick Broida completed the hardware installation in just 10 minutes, noting that the included QR code links to animated video guides that help visualize each step. The lock is designed to fit standard door preparations, supporting universal backsets of 2 3/8-inch or 2 3/4-inch and door thicknesses ranging from 1 3/8 to 1 3/4 inches. For most users replacing an existing deadbolt, the swap is a direct replacement that requires only a screwdriver.
However, Bob Vila’s Tony Carrick offered a more cautious perspective, noting that the installation can be challenging without a second pair of hands. The process involves aligning the exterior faceplate, interior casing, and bolt mechanism simultaneously while securing them with long screws, a task that can be fiddly if you are working alone. Carrick emphasized that while no structural changes to the door are typically needed, the physical coordination required to hold all components in place can be frustrating for novice installers. Additionally, the software setup, particularly for Apple HomeKit users, can be more complex than the hardware installation. Maxwell reported that adding the lock to Apple Home took a couple of attempts, suggesting that while the physical mounting is easy, the digital pairing process may require some patience. Overall, the installation is accessible for most DIYers, but having a helper can significantly reduce the stress of aligning the internal mechanisms.
Security Ratings and Build Quality
The Schlage Encode Plus boasts one of the highest security ratings available for residential smart locks, earning an ANSI/BHMA Grade 1 certification. Bob Vila’s Tony Carrick highlighted this as a major advantage, noting that it is the highest security rating for a residential door lock, surpassing many competitors that only achieve Grade 2 or Grade 3 ratings. The lock is constructed from zinc, providing a robust and durable feel that inspires confidence in its ability to withstand forced entry attempts. PCWorld’s Robert Strohmeyer also praised the build quality, describing the lock as 'imposing' and noting its classy looks. The lock is available in three trim styles—Camelot, Century, and Greenwich—with options for satin or matte-black finishes, allowing it to blend seamlessly with various home aesthetics. This combination of high-grade security and attractive design makes it a premium choice for homeowners who prioritize both safety and curb appeal.
Despite its high security rating, the lock’s physical design has drawn some criticism for being relatively bulky. PCWorld noted that the exterior portion measures 3 inches by 5 inches by 0.9 inches, while the interior portion is even larger at 3 inches by 5.5 inches by 2.2 inches. This bulkiness can be a concern for users with limited door space or those who prefer a more minimalist aesthetic. Additionally, the lock lacks an IP rating, meaning it is not officially certified for water resistance, although Schlage claims it can withstand temperatures ranging from -31 to 151°F. Reviewed.com’s Rick Broida pointed out that while the mechanical parts come with a lifetime warranty and the electronics are covered for three years, the lack of an IP rating leaves some uncertainty about its long-term durability in harsh weather conditions. For most indoor or sheltered outdoor applications, the build quality is excellent, but users in extreme climates may want to consider additional weatherproofing measures.
Battery Life and Power Management
Power management is a critical aspect of any smart lock, and the Schlage Encode Plus performs well in this area. The lock is powered by four AA batteries, which Schlage claims will last up to six months under normal usage conditions. Reviewed.com’s Rick Broida praised the outstanding battery life, noting that it is one of the standout features of the device. The lock also includes low-battery warnings to alert users before the power runs out, ensuring that they are not locked out unexpectedly. Additionally, the lock features a physical key override, providing a reliable backup method in case of a complete battery failure or electronic malfunction. This dual-layer approach to power management ensures that users have multiple options for accessing their home, even in the event of a power outage or technical issue.
However, some users have reported that battery life can vary depending on usage patterns and environmental conditions. Bob Vila’s Tony Carrick noted that frequent use of the keypad and remote access features can drain the batteries more quickly than Schlage’s estimated six-month lifespan. Additionally, the lock’s auto-lock feature, which relocks the door after a designated period of inactivity, can contribute to faster battery depletion if set to a short timer. Users who rely heavily on remote access or have high-traffic households may need to replace the batteries more frequently than the advertised duration. Despite this, the use of standard AA batteries is a significant advantage, as they are widely available and easy to replace, unlike proprietary battery packs found in some competing smart locks. Overall, the battery performance is solid, but users should monitor usage patterns to ensure they are not caught off guard by a sudden power loss.
Software Features and User Experience
The Schlage Home app serves as the central hub for managing the Encode Plus, offering a range of features designed to enhance convenience and security. Users can create up to 100 custom access codes, each with customizable timers and schedules, allowing for precise control over who can access the home and when. The app also provides real-time notifications for lock and unlock events, giving users peace of mind by confirming the status of their door at any time. NYT Wirecutter’s Adrienne Maxwell appreciated the ability to check the lock’s status remotely, which helped alleviate her anxiety about whether the door was properly secured. The app’s interface is intuitive, with a large button in the center of the screen that displays the lock’s current status, making it easy to lock or unlock the door with a single tap.
However, the app experience is not without its flaws. PCWorld’s Robert Strohmeyer noted that the reliance on the Schlage Home app for Google and Alexa users can be frustrating, as it prevents full integration with their native ecosystems. Additionally, some users have reported occasional connectivity issues, particularly when the lock is located far from the Wi-Fi router. The lock operates on 2.4GHz Wi-Fi, which can be prone to interference in homes with multiple devices or weak signal strength. While the lock’s integrated Wi-Fi eliminates the need for a hub, it also means that any issues with the home network can directly impact the lock’s functionality. Users with robust Wi-Fi networks will likely experience fewer problems, but those with weaker signals may need to consider a Wi-Fi extender to ensure reliable connectivity.
Where It Falls Short
Despite its many strengths, the Schlage Encode Plus has several notable drawbacks that potential buyers should consider. One of the most significant criticisms is the lack of a fingerprint reader, a feature that is becoming increasingly common in premium smart locks. Reviewed.com’s Rick Broida pointed out that the absence of biometric authentication limits the lock’s convenience and security options, particularly for users who prefer a hands-free unlocking experience. Additionally, the lock does not support geofencing, which means it cannot automatically unlock or lock the door based on the user’s proximity. This feature is available on some competing models, such as the U-Bolt Pro Wi-Fi, which Reviewed.com noted as a more affordable alternative with additional smart features. The lack of these advanced capabilities may disappoint users who are looking for a more futuristic and automated home security solution.
Another concern is the lock’s relatively high price point. At an MSRP of $299 to $319, the Encode Plus is one of the most expensive residential smart locks on the market. Bob Vila’s Tony Carrick questioned whether the premium price is justified, especially given the lock’s limited feature set compared to some competitors. While the ANSI Grade 1 security rating and broad smart home compatibility are valuable, they may not be enough to sway budget-conscious buyers who can find similar functionality at a lower cost. Additionally, the lock’s bulky design and lack of an IP rating may be dealbreakers for users with specific aesthetic or environmental requirements. For those who prioritize cutting-edge features like fingerprint scanning or geofencing, the Encode Plus may not be the best fit, despite its strong performance in other areas.
Who It Is Best For
The Schlage Encode Plus is an ideal choice for homeowners who are deeply invested in the Apple ecosystem and want a smart lock that seamlessly integrates with HomeKit and Apple Home Key. Reviewed.com’s Rick Broida described it as the best smart lock for HomeKit users, praising its support for NFC-based unlocking with iPhones and Apple Watches. The lock’s broad compatibility with Alexa and Google Home also makes it a versatile option for users who want to switch between platforms without replacing their hardware. Additionally, the ANSI Grade 1 security rating and robust build quality make it a strong choice for homeowners who prioritize safety and durability. The lifetime warranty on mechanical parts and three-year warranty on electronics provide further peace of mind, ensuring that the lock will remain functional for years to come. For users who value a premium, secure, and widely compatible smart lock, the Encode Plus is a top contender.
However, the lock may not be the best fit for budget-conscious buyers or those who prioritize advanced features like fingerprint scanning and geofencing. Bob Vila’s Tony Carrick noted that the high price point and limited feature set may not justify the investment for users who can find similar functionality at a lower cost. Additionally, the lock’s bulky design and lack of an IP rating may be unsuitable for users with specific aesthetic or environmental requirements. For those who are looking for a more affordable option with additional smart features, competitors like the U-Bolt Pro Wi-Fi may be a better choice. Ultimately, the Schlage Encode Plus is best suited for homeowners who value security, compatibility, and brand reputation, and are willing to pay a premium for these attributes. Shoppers who need a highly secure, widely compatible lock will find this a strong fit; those who care more about advanced biometric features or lower costs should look elsewhere.
Strengths
- +Supports Amazon Alexa, Google Home, and Apple HomeKit including Apple Home Key NFC technology
- +Integrated Wi-Fi eliminates the need for a separate bridge or hub
- +Easy physical installation with clearly labeled parts and a straightforward manual
- +Includes a physical key as a backup and works standalone without an app
Watch-outs
- −Google Home and Alexa apps require the Schlage Home app to function properly
- −Construction is relatively bulky compared to some other smart locks
- −Lacks a fingerprint reader for biometric access
How it compares
The Schlage Encode Plus stands out against the Level Lock+ and August Wi-Fi Smart Lock by offering native Apple Home Key support and integrated Wi-Fi without needing a bridge, a convenience the Level Lock+ lacks without an extra purchase. Although it shares the bulky design of the August and Ultraloq, it provides a physical key backup that the August lacks entirely, ensuring access even if the app fails.
Who this is for
At a glance: Homeowners seeking broad ecosystem compatibility and Apple Home Key without a bridge.
Why you’d buy the Schlage Encode Plus Smart WiFi Deadbolt
- Supports Amazon Alexa, Google Home, and Apple HomeKit including Apple Home Key NFC technology.
- Integrated Wi-Fi eliminates the need for a separate bridge or hub.
- Easy physical installation with clearly labeled parts and a straightforward manual.
Why you’d skip it
- Google Home and Alexa apps require the Schlage Home app to function properly.
- Construction is relatively bulky compared to some other smart locks.
- Lacks a fingerprint reader for biometric access.
Rating sources
Our 4.3 score is the average of these published ratings. More about methodology.
