The Salomon Quest 5 GTX remains a top-tier backpacking boot offering exceptional support, protection, and durability for heavy loads and rough terrain. Reviews from Hiking Feet and Better Trail confirm its superior ankle stability and waterproof performance, though it's noted as heavy and less flexible than modern alternatives. The boot is best suited for serious backpackers carrying substantial packs rather than casual day hikers or those seeking lightweight comfort. While it delivers on its promise of rugged reliability, its stiffness and weight may not appeal to lighter users or those prioritizing breathability.
Full review
Built for Durability
The Salomon Quest 5 GTX stands out for its robust construction and proven track record in demanding conditions. Outdoor Gear Lab's review highlighted that the boot's 4D Advanced Chassis provides a predictable footbed and cradles the heel while allowing natural forefoot flex. The boot's design includes a tall waterproofing flood height exceeding 8 inches, which effectively keeps trail debris out during hikes. According to the same review, the reinforced ankle collar and gusseted tongue contribute significantly to overall protection. The Quest 5's upper features rip-stop mesh in low-stress areas, preventing tears during extended use, as confirmed by testing in rugged Idaho terrain. The toe bumper is described as one of the most robust in the hiking boot market, offering excellent protection against sharp objects that could pierce through lesser footwear.
Ankle Support and Stability
Hiking Feet and Switchback Travel both emphasized the Quest 5's exceptional ankle support, which is a key selling point for serious backpackers. The boot's tall upper wraps fully around the ankle with a firm but not overly rigid collar, scoring 4.5/5 for support and stability in Better Trail's review. Outdoor Gear Lab noted that the integrated plastic 4D Advanced Chassis supports the heel and extends three-quarters of the way forward, providing rear foot stability while allowing forefoot flex. The lacing system includes a locking cleat that maintains tension independently of the upper, ensuring consistent support even under heavy loads. Mountaineer Journey's reviewer, a trail guide with 16 years of experience, rated the overall protection at 5/5, citing the boot's ability to prevent ankle rolls or twists during challenging terrain. The combination of a supportive upper, well-shaped heel cup, and stable platform underfoot allows for confident movement on uneven ground, especially when carrying packs over 25 pounds.
Comfort and Fit
Comfort ratings varied across reviews, with Outdoor Gear Lab giving the Quest 5 an 8.5/10 for comfort, while Better Trail scored it 3.5/5. The boot's fit is described as roomier than previous versions, with a wider toe box and improved midsole cushioning. Hiking Feet reported that the Quest 5's build balances stability with agility, though it's not as narrow in the toes as most Salomons. The new Ortholite sockliner and widened mid portion of the boot improved step-in comfort significantly. Mountaineer Journey's reviewer noted that the insole offers better shock absorption than previous iterations, resulting in fresher legs during long hikes. However, the boot's stiffness can be off-putting for lighter hikers or those preferring flexibility. The lacing system allows for different tension in foot and ankle areas, enabling users to snug up the ankles while leaving the laces loose around the feet for extra room. Despite these adjustments, some reviewers found the boot's bulkiness and lack of agility to be drawbacks, particularly for casual trail use.
Traction Performance
Salomon's Contagrip TA rubber compound delivers solid traction across various surfaces, with Better Trail rating it 4/5 and Mountaineer Journey giving it 8.5/10. The Quest 5 features double lugs on the medial and lateral aspects of the entire outsole, providing better edge-holding capabilities on rocky, uneven terrain. The heel lugs are placed in a reverse pattern to create more friction during steep descents, particularly on gravel. The boot's lug pattern favors easy cruising and typical backpacking environments, though it still has limitations in wet terrain. Switchback Travel's reviewer noted that while the traction is impressive, there were instances of slipping on wet limestone. The tread design effectively sheds snow and mud, with a deep heel brake for slowing down on steep descents in snow, mud, or gravel. However, the heel width narrows slightly towards the heel, which could be improved with a flared heel design. The boot performed well on rocky, uneven terrain, limestone, granite, loose gravel, packed dirt, and wet rock, but the traction score reflects its limitations in consistently wet conditions.
Weight and Performance
The Quest 5 weighs 2 lbs 10 oz for men's size 12, making it relatively light for a serious backpacking boot, though heavier than most day hiking footwear. Hiking Feet noted that it weighs less than 3 lbs, slightly lighter than most backpacking boots in their collection. Outdoor Gear Lab rated the weight at 6.4/10, acknowledging that while it's surprisingly lightweight for its level of protection, it's still bulky and not particularly nimble. The boot's weight is balanced with its protective features, making it suitable for heavy loads but less ideal for quick or casual hikes. Switchback Travel's reviewer found the Quest Prime GTX reasonably lightweight at 2 lbs 5.4 oz for women's size 8, but noted it felt noticeably less sprightly and clunkier than other boots they've worn. The boot's design prioritizes protection and support over agility, which is evident in its performance under heavy loads and rough terrain. For those seeking a balance between weight and protection, the Quest 5 offers a compelling option, though it's not the lightest choice available.
Where It Falls Short
Despite its many strengths, the Quest 5 has notable drawbacks that potential buyers should consider. The boot's stiffness and bulkiness make it unsuitable for casual hikers or those who prioritize flexibility and lightweight options. Better Trail's review pointed out that the Quest 5 is 'heavier than many modern hiking boots and trail-runner-inspired options' and 'not as narrow as some Salomons,' which may not appeal to all users. The lack of wide sizing options is another limitation, with Hiking Feet noting that while the fit is roomier than previous versions, it's still not available in wide widths. The boot's performance on solid rock is described as 'not quite as good' compared to its performance in mixed terrain. Additionally, the lacing system, while improved, can be slightly annoying to adjust, and the overall design reduces agility, making it overkill for casual trail use. Outdoor Gear Lab's reviewers noted that while the Quest 5 offers outstanding ankle support, it's 'bulky and not particularly nimble,' making it overkill for casual hikes.
Who It's Best For
The Salomon Quest 5 GTX is best suited for serious backpackers who prioritize ankle support, protection, and stability over weight and agility. Hiking Feet and Mountaineer Journey both recommend it for those who carry heavy packs and hike on demanding terrain. The boot is ideal for individuals with larger frames or those who need significant ankle support, as noted by Better Trail's testing across various users. It's particularly well-suited for long-distance hiking and backpacking trips where durability and protection are paramount. The Quest 5 excels in rugged environments, offering excellent support for heavy loads and challenging terrain. However, it's not recommended for casual hikers or those who prefer lightweight, flexible options. The boot's performance is best for those who prioritize stability and confidence underfoot over shaving ounces. For hikers who primarily use trails without significant elevation changes or heavy loads, lighter alternatives like the Salomon X Ultra 5 or Asolo Falcon GV might be more appropriate.
How It Compares to Alternatives
Compared to other high-end hiking boots, the Quest 5 holds its own in terms of protection and support. Outdoor Gear Lab ranked it #3 of 18 hiking boots, with strong scores for support (9.0/10) and traction (8.0/10). The Quest 5 is positioned as a premium backpacking boot that delivers exceptional ankle support without adding unnecessary weight, making it competitive with the Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX and other heavy-duty options. Switchback Travel's reviewer noted that while the Quest Prime GTX is comfortable and durable, it felt bulkier and less sprightly than other modern designs. The Quest 5's 4D Advanced Chassis provides a unique blend of stiffness and flexibility that sets it apart from competitors. When compared to the Salomon X Ultra 5, the Quest 5 offers more ankle support and stability, though the X Ultra 5 is lighter and more agile. The Quest 5's performance in wet conditions is slightly less impressive than some competitors, but its overall protection and support make it a strong contender for serious backpackers.
Strengths
- +Excellent ankle support and stability for heavy packs and rugged terrain
- +Highly protective design with strong impact resistance around and under the foot
- +Gore-Tex membrane and tall cut keep water out effectively
- +Durable construction that holds up well to rough use over time
- +Comfortable under load with dense EVA cushioning and shock absorption
Watch-outs
- −Stiff, structured feel not suitable for lighter hikers or those preferring flexibility
- −Heavier than many modern hiking boots at 2 lbs 10 oz
- −Limited breathability due to Gore-Tex lining
How it compares
The Salomon Quest 5 GTX provides unmatched ankle support and protection, surpassing the Hoka Kaha 3 GTX in stability for heavy packs, but it's heavier and less comfortable for long-distance hiking. Compared to the Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof, it offers superior protection and durability but at a higher price and with less breathability. It's the top choice for serious backpackers who need rugged reliability.
Who this is for
At a glance: serious backpackers needing durability.
Why you’d buy the Salomon Quest 5 Gore-Tex
- Excellent ankle support and stability for heavy packs and rugged terrain.
- Highly protective design with strong impact resistance around and under the foot.
- Gore-Tex membrane and tall cut keep water out effectively.
Why you’d skip it
- Stiff, structured feel not suitable for lighter hikers or those preferring flexibility.
- Heavier than many modern hiking boots at 2 lbs 10 oz.
- Limited breathability due to Gore-Tex lining.
Rating sources
Our 4.7 score is the average of these published ratings. More about methodology.
