Head-to-head · Best Laser Engravers

Atomstack A5 Pro vs xTool P2 10W

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

The short answer

xTool P2 10W comes out ahead by a narrow margin (4.0 vs 4.3). The gap is mostly about users wanting robust performance — read the strengths below before deciding.

Ranked #2 in Best Laser Engravers

Atomstack A5 Pro

4.0

$149.99as of Jul 7

The Atomstack A5 Pro is a 20W diode laser engraver with fixed focus design that simplifies operation. Reviewers noted its ease of assembly and included protective shroud, though it lacks endstops for automatic positioning. The laser outputs 5-5.5W optical power, which is lower than the electrical input rating. Users appreciate its compatibility with standard laser software and ability to work with various materials including wood, plastic, and leather. It's best suited for beginners or hobbyists seeking a straightforward engraving solution.

Strengths

— Fixed focus laser design eliminates need for manual focusing
— Includes protective acrylic shroud for added safety
— Supports multiple engraving materials including wood, plastic, and leather

Watch-outs

— No endstops included for automatic homing
— Laser output power is 5-5.5W despite 20W input rating

$149.99 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Higher ratedRanked #1 in Best Laser Engravers

xTool P2 10W

4.3

$3,249as of Jul 7

The xTool P2 is a powerful 55-watt CO2 desktop laser cutter that stands out with unique features like curved engraving and automated AI batch engraving. CNET called it a potential Glowforge killer, and reviewer Chris Garrett was impressed by its capabilities after just a day of testing. The machine comes fully enclosed with built-in fume extraction and air assist, making it safer to operate. It's designed for users who need robust performance for thicker materials or faster engraving speeds. However, it requires a significant initial setup with distilled water and antifreeze, and its large footprint may not suit all workspaces.

Strengths

— 55-watt CO2 laser provides substantial cutting and engraving power
— Built-in fume extraction and air assist for safer operation
— Curved Engraving feature automatically adjusts z-height for warped materials

Watch-outs

— Requires distilled water and included antifreeze before first use
— Machine size is substantial at 39.4×25.1×10.6 inches

$3,249 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

How they stack up

Atomstack A5 Pro

The Atomstack A5 Pro's fixed focus design and protective shroud make it more beginner-friendly than the Ortur Laser Engraver 4, which requires complex alignment. However, it's less powerful than the xTool D1 Pro and lacks the large cutting area and included software tutorials that make the D1 Pro more accessible.

xTool P2 10W

The xTool P2 stands out from the Glowforge Pro with its fully enclosed design and built-in fume extraction, features that the Glowforge lacks without an expensive add-on. Compared to the xTool D1 Pro, it offers more power with its 55-watt CO2 laser and includes advanced AI batch engraving, but requires more setup effort and has a larger footprint.

Specs side-by-side

Spec	Atomstack A5 Pro	xTool P2 10W
Laser Power	20W	55 Watt CO₂
Laser Type	Diode Laser	CO2 Laser
Work Area	410*400mm	26.7×14.1 (680*360mm)
Software	ATOMSTACK Studio Software	xTool Creative Space / LightBurn
Machine Size	410 x 400 mm	39.4×25.1×10.6 (1000×639×268mm)
Weight	8.82 lb	99.2 lb
Max Speed	—	600mm/s

← See the full ranking of best laser engravers