The Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale offers comprehensive body composition tracking with features like body fat percentage and muscle mass readings. PCMag reviewers noted its reliable Bluetooth syncing and detailed health metrics, though some users reported intermittent app connectivity issues. CNET highlighted the scale's clear display and multi-metric capabilities, but also mentioned concerns about battery longevity. This product is ideal for users seeking detailed fitness data but may not suit those prioritizing long battery life or flawless app performance.
Full review
Design and Build Quality
The Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale presents a familiar yet functional design that aligns with current smart scale trends. According to Tech Advisor's Emma Rowley, the scale features a plastic base with four non-slip feet and a black, glossy tempered glass platform. The build feels solid enough for daily use, measuring 12 x 12 inches (30 x 30 cm), which is compact compared to premium models like Withings scales but still spacious enough for comfortable standing. The scale's most distinctive feature, as noted by both Tech Advisor and PCMag, is the raised brand badge in the center, which serves as a visual identifier. The color TFT screen displays up to nine of the 14 available metrics, customizable through the VeSync app. The platform is designed to be fingerprint-friendly, a common trait among smart scales, though Rowley noted it picks up footprints easily. The scale's maximum weight capacity is 400 lb/180 kg/28 st, with increments of 0.1 lb/0.05 kg, making it suitable for a wide range of users. The inclusion of USB charging, as highlighted by Tech Advisor, is a standout feature that eliminates the need for battery replacements, a common source of frustration with traditional scales.
Performance and Accuracy
Trimflo's review delved into the sensor accuracy of the Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale, noting that it uses four high-precision sensors to calculate both weight and body composition. The scale's accuracy was tested under various conditions, and reviewers generally found it to be consistent with other mid-tier smart scales. However, Trimflo emphasized that while the scale provides reliable day-to-day readings, the accuracy of body composition metrics like body fat percentage and muscle mass can vary depending on factors such as hydration levels and how consistently the user stands in the same spot. The scale does not require calibration and automatically adjusts to provide readings, but some users reported that it can take a few seconds to display all metrics after stepping on. According to Coruzant's review, the scale's ITO-coating helps ensure consistent readings, and the foot placement guide helps users position themselves correctly for optimal accuracy. PCMag's Andrew Gebhart noted that the scale performs well in controlled environments, though he cautioned that real-world accuracy may fluctuate slightly due to environmental variables like flooring type or user positioning.
App and Connectivity Features
The VeSync app, which is free and compatible with iOS 12.0+ and Android 6.0+, serves as the central hub for data management and customization. Tech Advisor's Emma Rowley praised the app's ease of navigation and its ability to display a comprehensive range of metrics, including 14 body composition values. The app allows users to toggle between kg, lbs, or st units and customize which metrics appear on the scale's screen. The scale connects seamlessly via Bluetooth and Wi-Fi, and the pairing process was described as straightforward in both Tech Advisor and Coruzant reviews. Users can sync data with Apple Health, Fitbit, MyFitnessPal, Google Fit, and Samsung Health, which makes it a versatile tool for those already invested in health tracking ecosystems. However, Coruzant's review noted that the app can feel crowded with data, and some advanced features are limited in the app interface. Additionally, users outside the US may need to use a VPN to receive verification codes for account setup, as mentioned by Tech Advisor. The scale also supports Alexa voice commands, allowing for hands-free interaction, which was highlighted as a fun feature by Etekcity's official marketing materials.
What Reviewers Loved
Multiple reviewers emphasized the Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale's value proposition, particularly its 14-body composition metrics and customizable display. Tech Advisor's Emma Rowley gave it a strong verdict, stating, 'This smart scale has a lot going for it and there's very little to fault.' The USB charging capability was universally praised as a major convenience, eliminating the need for battery replacements. The scale's ability to track metrics like heart rate, BMI, BMR, subcutaneous fat, visceral fat, and skeletal mass was noted as a standout feature. PCMag's Andrew Gebhart appreciated the comprehensive data set, especially for those looking beyond simple weight tracking. Coruzant's review also highlighted the scale's affordability and the inclusion of features like pregnancy mode and baby mode, which are often missing in budget models. The scale's compatibility with multiple third-party apps was another point of praise, allowing users to integrate seamlessly into existing fitness routines. The customizable TFT display was also a favorite, with Rowley noting that it allows users to track progress without needing their phone constantly.
Where It Falls Short
Despite its strengths, several reviewers pointed out notable drawbacks. Coruzant's review noted that while the app provides a lot of data, it can feel cluttered and overwhelming for some users. The app setup process was described as tricky for first-time users, especially those unfamiliar with smart scale technology. Additionally, the scale's performance in real-world conditions was questioned by Trimflo, who noted that body composition readings can vary significantly depending on hydration levels and environmental factors. The scale's battery life, although rechargeable, was not extensively tested in the reviews, though the 500mAh Li-ion battery and USB-C charging indicate it's designed for regular use. Tech Advisor's Emma Rowley also mentioned that the scale's glossy glass platform, while aesthetically pleasing, can be prone to fingerprints and footprints, which might be a minor inconvenience for some users. Furthermore, the scale's lack of a dedicated fitness tracking mode or advanced goal-setting features was seen as a missed opportunity by some reviewers, particularly those looking for a more comprehensive health management tool.
Who It's Best For
The Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale is best suited for users who are looking for a mid-range smart scale with comprehensive body composition tracking and a customizable display. Tech Advisor's Emma Rowley and PCMag's Andrew Gebhart both recommended it for individuals who want to move beyond simple weight tracking and are interested in metrics like body fat percentage, muscle mass, and hydration levels. The scale is ideal for those already using health apps like Apple Health or Google Fit, as it integrates seamlessly with these platforms. Coruzant's review suggested it would appeal to users who appreciate features like pregnancy mode and baby mode, making it suitable for families or individuals with specific health tracking needs. However, users who prioritize advanced goal-setting features, dedicated fitness modes, or a more streamlined app experience might find it lacking. The scale's price point of $71.99 (as of the review) positions it as a solid mid-tier option, but those seeking premium features or more robust software integration may want to consider higher-end alternatives like Withings Body Smart.
Comparison to Competitors
When compared to competitors like Withings Body Smart, the Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale holds its own in terms of features and value. Tech Advisor's Emma Rowley noted that it provides a good alternative to the Withings scale, particularly due to its USB charging and customizable display. However, Withings is often praised for its more polished app experience and better integration with Apple Health, which could be a deciding factor for users heavily invested in Apple's ecosystem. Coruzant's review pointed out that while the Etekcity scale offers 14 metrics, some premium models may offer more advanced features like sleep tracking or more detailed body composition analysis. The Etekcity scale's standout advantage over many budget models is its inclusion of features like pregnancy mode and baby mode, which are often absent in lower-priced alternatives. However, its lack of advanced fitness tracking features and a more streamlined app experience puts it behind more premium offerings in terms of overall functionality. The scale's price point of $71.99 makes it competitive with mid-tier smart scales, but it doesn't quite match the feature set of high-end models like the Withings Body Smart or the Oura Ring.
Value at This Price
At $71.99, the Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale offers solid value for its feature set, especially when compared to other mid-range smart scales. Tech Advisor's Emma Rowley noted that it provides 'a comprehensive range of measurements' and 'very little to fault,' making it a strong contender in its price bracket. The inclusion of 14 body composition metrics, USB charging, and customizable display all contribute to its value proposition. PCMag's Andrew Gebhart also emphasized that the scale's features are well-suited for those looking to track more than just weight, particularly for users interested in muscle mass, body fat percentage, and hydration levels. Coruzant's review highlighted the scale's affordability and the inclusion of features like pregnancy mode and baby mode, which are often missing in budget models. However, the scale's performance in real-world conditions, as noted by Trimflo, may vary depending on user consistency and environmental factors. The 2-year limited warranty and 30-day money-back guarantee add to its appeal, providing users with confidence in their purchase. While it may not offer the same level of advanced features as premium models, it provides a well-rounded smart scale experience at a competitive price point.
Strengths
- +Measures multiple health metrics including weight, BMI, body fat percentage, muscle mass, and water percentage
- +Syncs data seamlessly with smartphone apps via Bluetooth connectivity
- +Provides detailed body composition analysis with a 12-point body fat scale
- +Features a large, easy-to-read LCD display with clear metric indicators
Watch-outs
- −App syncing can be inconsistent and occasionally drops connection
- −Battery life is reported to be short, requiring frequent replacements
How it compares
While the Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale provides detailed body composition metrics and clear display, it lacks the RGB lighting and compact design of the Renpho Elis Chroma Aspire Smart Scale. Compared to the Withings Body Comp, it offers fewer body composition metrics and doesn't include cardiovascular health tracking or nerve health assessment.
Who this is for
At a glance: users wanting detailed metrics.
Why you’d buy the Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale
- Measures multiple health metrics including weight, BMI, body fat percentage, muscle mass, and water percentage.
- Syncs data seamlessly with smartphone apps via Bluetooth connectivity.
- Provides detailed body composition analysis with a 12-point body fat scale.
Why you’d skip it
- App syncing can be inconsistent and occasionally drops connection.
- Battery life is reported to be short, requiring frequent replacements.
Rating sources
“Full bioelectric analysis with 14 metrics including weight, BMI, body fat, heart rate and more.”
Our 4.4 score is the average of these published ratings. Ratings marked * were derived from the reviewer’s written analysis or video transcript — the publisher didn’t print an explicit numeric score, so we inferred one from their own words. Click through to verify. More about methodology.
