Head-to-head · Best Outdoor Rugs

Loloi II Easton ESN-06 Ivory/Green Reversible Indoor/Outdoor Rug vs Mad Mats Mix Tropical Reversible Recycled Plastic Outdoor Rug

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

The short answer

Loloi II Easton ESN-06 Ivory/Green Reversible Indoor/Outdoor Rug comes out ahead by a narrow margin (4.5 vs 4.4). The gap is mostly about Buyers who want a designer-look polypropylene rug with the practical benefit of a flippable second pattern — read the strengths below before deciding.

Higher ratedRanked #4 in Best Outdoor Rugs

Loloi II Easton ESN-06 Ivory/Green Reversible Indoor/Outdoor Rug

4.5

$419

The Loloi II Easton ESN-06 is the design-forward pick in the lineup — power-loomed in Turkey from a 93/7 polypropylene-polyester blend, with a genuinely reversible two-tone pattern that lets you flip seasons or refresh a tired-looking side. The 5'-3"x7'-6" lands around $200; the 7'-10"x10' runs $400-500. Loloi's design partnerships make this the rug to buy when you want a polypropylene rug that doesn't look like a polypropylene rug.

Strengths

— Genuinely reversible — two distinct colorways on the same rug for seasonal flipping
— 93% polypropylene / 7% polyester power-loomed in Turkey for tight weave consistency
— Seven sizes from 2'-3"x3'-9" accent through 8'-6"x11'-6" plus a sample swatch

Watch-outs

— Pricing climbs sharply at larger sizes — the 7'-10"x10' lands around $400-500
— Power-loomed polypropylene is functional, not plush — buyers expecting softness were the most disappointed
— Ships rolled and can take several days under weights to lie completely flat

$419 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Ranked #5 in Best Outdoor Rugs

Mad Mats Mix Tropical Reversible Recycled Plastic Outdoor Rug

4.4

$175

The Mad Mats Mix Tropical is the sustainability and value pick — hand-loomed in Thailand from 100% recycled plastic tubes, fully reversible, with a one-year color guarantee. At $175 for the 5x8 and $225 for the 6x9, it lands at roughly half the price-per-square-foot of the Loloi Easton or Ruggable Josephine in equivalent sizes. The trade-off is texture (plastic ribbon, not soft polypropylene) and sizing (caps at 6x9). Mad Mats reviewers have reported owning the same rug for 10+ years with continued performance.

Strengths

— Made of 100% recycled plastic — the most sustainable construction in the lineup
— Hand-loomed in Thailand from recycled polypropylene tubes for genuine artisanal weave
— Fully reversible with distinct color patterns on each face

Watch-outs

— Open-weave construction lets dirt, sand, and pet hair fall through onto the surface below
— Hand-loomed sizing tops out at 6x9 — no 8x10 or larger for big patios
— Plastic-ribbon texture feels harder underfoot than polypropylene flatweaves like the Sabina or Easton

$175 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

How they stack up

Loloi II Easton ESN-06 Ivory/Green Reversible Indoor/Outdoor Rug

The Easton is the design pick vs the nuLOOM Sabina's neutral trellis and the Safavieh Beach House's coastal stripe — Loloi's pattern reads more curated. It also reverses, which the Sabina and Beach House don't. The Mad Mats Mix Tropical also reverses but is woven from recycled plastic ribbon (very different look). Pricewise the Easton sits between the Sabina ($358 at 8x10) and the Ruggable Josephine ($569 cover at 8x10).

Mad Mats Mix Tropical Reversible Recycled Plastic Outdoor Rug

The Mad Mats is the only recycled-plastic pick in this lineup — the Sabina, Beach House, and Easton are virgin polypropylene, the Ruggable Josephine is recycled polyester with a polyurethane barrier (not the same as Mad Mats' plastic-tube weave). At $175 for a 5x8 it competes on price with smaller Safavieh Beach House sizes but wins on sustainability and reversibility; it loses to the Beach House on size availability (Mad Mats caps at 6x9).

Specs side-by-side

Spec	Loloi II Easton ESN-06 Ivory/Green Reversible Indoor/Outdoor Rug	Mad Mats Mix Tropical Reversible Recycled Plastic Outdoor Rug
Available Sizes	7 (2'-3"x3'-9" through 8'-6"x11'-6")	4 (2'6"x6' runner, 4x6, 5x8, 6x9)
Material	93% polypropylene, 7% polyester (power-loomed in Turkey)	100% recycled polypropylene tubes (hand-loomed in Thailand)
Backing	None — flatweave both sides	None — open-weave both faces
Pile Height	Low flatweave (sub-0.25 in)	Flat ribbon weave (sub-0.2 in)
Washable	No — hose off and air dry outside	No — sweep, hose off, or wipe with mild detergent
UV Resistance	Polypropylene fiber base; covered/shaded use recommended	UV-coated for fade resistance — one-year color guarantee
Mildew Resistance	Yes — no moisture-absorbing fibers or backing	Yes — plastic fiber doesn't absorb water; open weave drains and dries fast
Cleaning Instructions	Vacuum without beater bar; hose off; professional cleaning for deep stains	—
Country of Origin	Turkey	—
Warranty	—	One-year color guarantee

← See the full ranking of best outdoor rugs