Verdict
Ranked #5 of 5Reviewed by Mike Hun·May 20, 2026

Oster Extra Large Digital

Averaged from + undefined
The verdict

The Oster XL is the large-capacity pick. French door design and 16" pizza capacity make it the right buy for households cooking for 4+ regularly.

Oster Extra Large Digital

Strengths

  • +Fits 16" pizza or 2 lb roast
  • +Digital touch panel with preset functions
  • +French door design opens both sides
  • +Convection setting

Watch-outs

  • Heating elements take longer to preheat
  • Touch panel less responsive than Breville's
  • Larger appliance — counter footprint matters

How it compares

Largest capacity. French door design unique. Slower preheat than Breville.

Who this is for

At a glance: families of 4+ cooking 16" pizzas and larger roasts.

Why you’d buy the Oster Extra Large Digital

  • Fits 16" pizza or 2 lb roast.
  • Digital touch panel with preset functions.
  • French door design opens both sides.

Why you’d skip it

  • Heating elements take longer to preheat.
  • Touch panel less responsive than Breville's.
  • Larger appliance — counter footprint matters.

Rating sources

Our 4.3 score is the average of these published ratings. More about methodology.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Oster Extra Large Digital worth buying?
The Oster XL is the large-capacity pick. French door design and 16" pizza capacity make it the right buy for households cooking for 4+ regularly.
What is the Oster Extra Large Digital's biggest strength?
Fits 16" pizza or 2 lb roast
What is the main drawback of the Oster Extra Large Digital?
Heating elements take longer to preheat
What sources back the 4.3/5 rating?
Our 4.3/5 rating is the average of scores from 1 independent toaster ovens under $200 review — bestbuy. Click any source on the product page to read the original review.

How it compares

See all 5
Oster Extra Large Digital
4.3/5· $150
Check Price on Amazon