The Kamado Joe Big Joe Series I 24-inch Ceramic Charcoal Grill and Smoker offers robust cooking capabilities with its 2-tier Divide & Conquer system and patented ash drawer for easy cleanup. Reviewers noted the Cast Iron Top Vent for precise temperature control and built-in thermometer for accuracy. However, some found the 450 square-inch cooking surface limiting for large gatherings, and the 358.9-pound weight makes it cumbersome despite included locking wheels. This grill is best suited for serious home cooks who value functionality over portability.
Full review
Design and Build Quality
The Kamado Joe Big Joe Series I 24-inch grill presents a robust, premium build that reflects its position as a high-end backyard cooking solution. Constructed with heavy-duty ceramic, the grill measures 58.3 inches in width and 52.8 inches in height, weighing in at 358.9 pounds. This substantial weight contributes to the grill's stability and heat retention capabilities, though it does present logistical challenges during delivery and setup. According to the Kamado Joe website, the grill features a 450 square-inch cooking surface, which is ideal for entertaining larger groups. The ceramic construction is complemented by a powder-coated steel cart with locking wheels, making it mobile while maintaining structural integrity. The design includes a patented slide-out ash drawer, a built-in thermometer, and folding HDPE side shelves for extra preparation space. These features, combined with a cast iron top vent and stainless steel cooking grates, indicate a thoughtful approach to both functionality and durability.
Professional reviewers have noted that the Big Joe Series I's ceramic construction is among the most durable in the market. The ceramic shell is designed to retain heat efficiently, which is essential for maintaining consistent cooking temperatures. The inclusion of a built-in thermometer and cast iron top vent allows for precise temperature control, a feature that several reviewers have highlighted as particularly effective. The grill's ability to maintain temperature even in fluctuating weather conditions was tested by the YouTube reviewer who noted that the dual damper system made temperature management straightforward. However, the assembly process, while well-documented, is described as requiring significant physical effort, with one reviewer noting that lifting the 300-pound grill into the cart was the trickiest part of setup. The ceramic pieces, while robust, require careful alignment during assembly, and reviewers have suggested using paper towels as temporary stabilizers to avoid frustration during this stage.
Cooking Performance
The Big Joe Series I delivers impressive cooking performance, particularly in terms of temperature control and heat retention. Reviewers have consistently praised its ability to maintain stable temperatures, even under challenging conditions. During a test run, one reviewer noted that the grill stabilized at 350°F (177°C) after a proper burn-in period, which is ideal for grilling items like spatchcocked chicken. The 2-tier Divide & Conquer Flexible Cooking System allows users to prepare multiple dishes simultaneously at varying temperatures, a feature that was particularly appreciated by users who frequently entertain guests. The system's half-moon shaped heat deflector plates enable the creation of both direct and indirect heat zones, providing flexibility in cooking methods. The grill's efficiency was also noted by a reviewer who mentioned that despite its large size, it consumed minimal charcoal, making it fuel-efficient for extended cooking sessions.
The grill's temperature control is facilitated by a dual damper system that includes both top and bottom vents. Reviewers have reported that this system is easy to manage, even for newcomers to kamado-style grilling. The air lift hinge, while not present in the Series I model, is a feature that has been noted in later models and contributes to easier lid operation. The grill's ceramic construction and well-designed airflow system work together to ensure that heat is distributed evenly across the cooking surface. One reviewer highlighted that the grill's ability to maintain temperature even during Florida weather fluctuations was impressive. The cooking surface, with its 450 square inches of space, allows for large cuts of meat or multiple items to be cooked simultaneously, which is especially valuable for family gatherings or outdoor events.
Features and Functionality
The Big Joe Series I comes equipped with several innovative features that distinguish it from standard charcoal grills. The 2-tier Divide & Conquer Flexible Cooking System is perhaps the most notable, allowing users to cook at different temperatures simultaneously. This system includes half-moon shaped heat deflector plates that can be adjusted to create both direct and indirect heat zones, enabling complex cooking strategies. The slide-out ash drawer simplifies cleanup, a feature that was praised by multiple reviewers for its convenience. The built-in thermometer provides precise temperature readings, which is essential for maintaining consistent cooking results. Additionally, the grill includes a cast iron top vent, stainless steel cooking grates, and folding HDPE side shelves for extra preparation space. These features combine to create a versatile cooking environment that supports a wide range of culinary techniques.
The grill's design includes a standard HDPE side shelf, which is foldable for added convenience during cooking. The included accessories, such as an ash tool and grate lifter, are well-suited for the grill's heavy-duty construction. The ceramic construction, while robust, requires a burn-in period before optimal performance. Reviewers have noted that this process is straightforward but essential for seasoning the ceramic interior. The included charcoal basket is designed to work with the grill's built-in features, and the overall system is designed to be user-friendly without sacrificing performance. The grill's ability to accommodate a variety of cooking methods, from high-heat searing to low-and-slow smoking, makes it a versatile addition to any outdoor kitchen setup.
User Experience and Setup
The setup process for the Big Joe Series I is described as straightforward but physically demanding, with reviewers noting that the 500-pound pallet delivery and the need to lift the heavy ceramic grill into the cart were the most challenging aspects. One reviewer from Dad Got This emphasized that while the assembly was manageable, it required assistance from a friend and careful attention to the instructions. The ceramic components must be aligned carefully, and the use of paper towels as temporary stabilizers was recommended by one reviewer to prevent misalignment during the firebox assembly. The inclusion of all necessary tools and clear instructions helps streamline the process, though the physical effort required is significant. The assembly process is described as well-thought-out, with components designed to work seamlessly together.
Once assembled, the grill's operation is intuitive, especially for those familiar with kamado-style grills. The dual damper system allows for precise temperature control, and the built-in thermometer provides accurate readings. Reviewers have noted that the grill's temperature stability is one of its strongest features, making it suitable for both novice and experienced cooks. The slide-out ash drawer and the included accessories contribute to a positive user experience by simplifying cleanup and enhancing convenience. The grill's mobility, thanks to its locking wheels, allows for easy relocation, though its substantial weight makes it best suited for permanent outdoor placement. Overall, the user experience is characterized by a balance of robust construction and user-friendly features.
What Reviewers Loved
Reviewers consistently praised the Big Joe Series I for its superior temperature control and heat retention capabilities. The ceramic construction was noted for its durability and efficiency in maintaining consistent cooking temperatures, even under fluctuating weather conditions. One reviewer from Abt.com highlighted that the grill's ability to hold temperature was impressive, particularly in Florida weather. The 2-tier Divide & Conquer Flexible Cooking System was also a favorite among reviewers, as it allows for simultaneous cooking at different temperatures, making it ideal for entertaining. The slide-out ash drawer was frequently mentioned as a convenient feature that simplifies cleanup. Additionally, the grill's fuel efficiency was noted, with reviewers stating that it consumed minimal charcoal while maintaining high heat, which is beneficial for both cost and environmental reasons.
The build quality and materials were also widely appreciated. Reviewers from multiple sources, including Abt.com and YouTube channels, emphasized the durability of the ceramic construction and the inclusion of stainless steel components. The powder-coated steel cart was noted for its sturdiness and the locking wheels that provide mobility without compromising stability. The grill's ability to handle a variety of cooking methods, from searing to smoking, was also a point of praise. One reviewer from Abt.com mentioned that the grill was versatile enough to be used for everything from high-heat grilling to low-and-slow smoking, making it a worthwhile investment for serious outdoor cooks. The included accessories, such as the ash tool and grate lifter, were also appreciated for their quality and suitability for the grill's heavy-duty design.
Where It Falls Short
Despite its many strengths, the Big Joe Series I is not without its drawbacks. The most significant limitation is its size and weight, which can be a challenge for users with limited space or physical strength. The 500-pound delivery and the need for assistance during setup were noted as major hurdles by several reviewers. The physical effort required to move the grill, even with the locking wheels, can be considerable. Additionally, while the ceramic construction is durable, it is also fragile and requires careful handling during transport and setup. The grill's price point of $1,499.99 is steep, and some reviewers have questioned whether the features justify the cost for casual users. The burn-in process, while necessary, is time-consuming and may be off-putting to those seeking immediate gratification.
Another area of concern is the lack of certain features that are available in higher-tier models. For example, the air lift hinge, which is standard in Series II and III models, is not included in the Series I. This can make lifting the lid more difficult, particularly for users with limited mobility. The absence of a digital temperature control system or other modern conveniences means that the grill relies on traditional methods of temperature management, which may not appeal to tech-savvy users. Some reviewers have also noted that the grill's performance can be inconsistent in extreme weather conditions, though this is mitigated by proper setup and maintenance. Overall, while the Big Joe Series I is a solid choice for serious outdoor cooks, it may not be the best fit for those seeking a more accessible or budget-friendly option.
Who It's Best For
The Kamado Joe Big Joe Series I is best suited for serious outdoor cooks who value performance, durability, and versatility. It is ideal for users who frequently entertain guests or who are passionate about grilling and smoking. The 2-tier Divide & Conquer Flexible Cooking System makes it particularly appealing to those who want to cook multiple items simultaneously at varying temperatures. The grill's ability to maintain consistent temperatures and its fuel efficiency make it a great choice for extended cooking sessions or low-and-slow smoking. Users who have experience with kamado-style grills or who are willing to invest time in learning the system will find the Big Joe Series I to be a rewarding investment. The grill is also well-suited for those who appreciate the craftsmanship and build quality that comes with premium outdoor cooking equipment.
However, the Big Joe Series I may not be ideal for casual users or those with limited space. The substantial weight and size of the grill make it less practical for smaller outdoor areas or for users who lack the physical strength to handle it. The price point of $1,499.99 is also a barrier for budget-conscious consumers. Those who prefer digital controls or modern conveniences may find the traditional methods of operation less appealing. Additionally, the setup process, while manageable, requires significant physical effort and assistance, which may not be feasible for all users. For individuals who are looking for a more accessible or affordable option, the Big Joe Series I may be overkill, though it remains an excellent choice for those who are serious about outdoor cooking.
Value at This Price
At $1,499.99, the Big Joe Series I represents a significant investment, but reviewers have generally found the value to be strong. The combination of premium materials, innovative features, and proven performance justifies the price for serious outdoor cooks. The ceramic construction, stainless steel components, and included accessories all contribute to a high-quality product that is built to last. The grill's ability to maintain consistent temperatures and its fuel efficiency are particularly valuable features that help offset the initial cost. Reviewers from multiple sources, including Abt.com and YouTube channels, have noted that the grill's versatility makes it a worthwhile investment for those who cook frequently outdoors. The included accessories, such as the ash tool and grate lifter, are of high quality and are well-suited to the grill's heavy-duty construction.
The warranty coverage, which includes a lifetime limited warranty for ceramic parts and 5-year coverage for metal and cast iron components, provides additional value. This level of warranty protection is indicative of the manufacturer's confidence in the product's durability. The grill's ability to handle a variety of cooking methods, from searing to smoking, makes it a versatile addition to any outdoor kitchen. While the price point is steep, reviewers have consistently emphasized that the Big Joe Series I delivers on its promises, making it a solid choice for those who are serious about outdoor cooking. The long-term value of the investment is further supported by the grill's robust construction and the positive feedback from users who have been using it for years.
Strengths
- +2-Tier Divide & Conquer Flexible Cooking System allows cooking multiple foods at various temperatures simultaneously
- +Patented Slide-Out Ash Drawer simplifies cleanup
- +Cast Iron Top Vent enables precise temperature control with adjustable airflow
- +Built-in thermometer provides accurate temperature monitoring
Watch-outs
- −Limited cooking space of 450 square inches may not suit large gatherings
- −Heavy weight at 358.9 lbs makes mobility difficult despite locking wheels
How it compares
The Big Joe Series I offers the largest cooking surface of all models, surpassing the Konnected Joe and Classic Joe in capacity. Unlike the Brand-Man Rodeo, it features the 2-tier Divide & Conquer system and Slide-Out Ash Drawer. While it's more robust than the Outvita and London Sunshine, it's significantly heavier and less portable than the other 13-inch models.
Who this is for
At a glance: Large gatherings and serious multi-tasking cooks.
Why you’d buy the Kamado Joe Big Joe Series I 24-inch Ceramic Charcoal Grill and Smoker with Cart,
- 2-Tier Divide & Conquer Flexible Cooking System allows cooking multiple foods at various temperatures simultaneously.
- Patented Slide-Out Ash Drawer simplifies cleanup.
- Cast Iron Top Vent enables precise temperature control with adjustable airflow.
Why you’d skip it
- Limited cooking space of 450 square inches may not suit large gatherings.
- Heavy weight at 358.9 lbs makes mobility difficult despite locking wheels.
Rating sources
“Supreme in size, the Big Joe I provides 24-inches of cooking space, perfect for entertaining a crowd.”
“Kamado Joe is the fastest growing brand in the Kamado industry for a reason. Introducing innovation with each new model, the kamado style cookers keep getting better and better.”
“If you're looking for a beast of a grill that combines craftsmanship, durability, and grilling performance, look no further than the Kamado Joe Big Joe Series III.”
“Overall Rating 4.9 542 Reviews 516 out of 519 (99%) reviewers recommend this product”
Our 4.6 score is the average of these published ratings. Ratings marked * were derived from the reviewer’s written analysis or video transcript — the publisher didn’t print an explicit numeric score, so we inferred one from their own words. Click through to verify. More about methodology.
