TechRadar reviewed the Amazon Echo Show 8 (2nd Gen) and noted its 8-inch LCD display with 1280x800 resolution as well-suited for kitchen use, particularly for cooking tutorials and media viewing from 5-6 feet away. The improved audio quality was highlighted as a positive feature. However, the packaging was criticized for being excessive. YouTube reviewer Art from Futex praised the screen size for kitchen use and setup simplicity, though mentioned subtitle readability as a drawback. This device is best for users seeking a mid-sized smart display for active kitchen spaces rather than those preferring smaller bedroom models.
Full review
Design Evolution
The Amazon Echo Show 8 (2nd Gen) maintains the same physical dimensions as its predecessor at 5.4 x 7.9 x 3.9 inches, but introduces a refined aesthetic with a spheroid base that makes the 8-inch screen appear to float in mid-air. This design shift, noted by PCWorld's Ben Patterson, represents a significant departure from the chunky wedge-shaped look of older Echo Show models, creating a sleeker, more modern appearance that fits better in contemporary living spaces. The screen itself remains flush with the LCD panel and features a half-inch frame, with the camera positioned in the top right corner. The fabric back panel matches the front frame color, available in black or white, and includes pinhole cutouts for far-field microphones, volume controls, and a mechanical privacy shutter switch.
TechRadar's review emphasized that while the design is visually appealing, it's not revolutionary, maintaining the same form factor and screen specifications as the first generation. However, the spheroid base and floating screen presentation are described as a notable improvement over previous models, with the screen's edge-to-edge display and rounded corners offering a more contemporary feel. The device's build quality and materials are consistent with Amazon's premium smart display line, though the lack of a privacy shutter in the newer models, as noted by CNET's reviewer, is a significant omission that privacy-conscious users may find concerning.
Audio Performance
Audio performance remains consistent with the original Echo Show 8, featuring dual 2.0-inch speaker drivers with a passive bass radiator, delivering robust sound for its size. PCWorld's Ben Patterson praised the audio quality, describing it as 'impressive' and noting that the speakers provide 'powerful audio for the size.' The Echo Show 8's audio system is capable of handling music streaming from services like Amazon Music, Apple Music, Spotify, and SiriusXM, as well as providing clear voice communication during video calls. The device supports both voice and touch-screen control for audio functions, with the ability to adjust volume through physical buttons or voice commands.
While the audio capabilities are solid, reviewers have noted that the speakers don't quite reach the level of high-end sound systems, but they're sufficient for most home entertainment needs. The lack of significant audio upgrades in the second-generation model, according to PCMag's Will Greenwald, means that users shouldn't expect a dramatic improvement in sound quality, though the existing system remains functional and pleasant for everyday use. The speakers' performance is adequate for casual listening, but audiophiles seeking premium sound may need to look elsewhere.
Camera and Video Capabilities
The most significant upgrade in the second-generation Echo Show 8 is the camera, which has been upgraded from 1MP to 13MP with auto-framing capabilities. This enhancement, highlighted by both PCMag and PCWorld reviewers, provides a much clearer and more focused video chat experience. The new camera supports digital pan and zoom, offering better framing and focus during video calls. According to PCMag's Will Greenwald, the camera upgrade is substantial enough to justify the second-generation model, especially for users who rely heavily on video communication.
However, the camera lacks the motorized tracking capabilities found in higher-end models like the Echo Show 10, which costs nearly twice as much. Despite this limitation, the 13MP camera with auto-framing is considered a significant improvement over the previous model's 1MP sensor. The camera's performance is particularly noticeable during video calls, where the clarity and framing are much better than before. The lack of motorized tracking, as noted by PCWorld's Ben Patterson, means that the camera doesn't automatically follow participants, but it still delivers a better video experience than its predecessor.
Smart Home Integration
The Echo Show 8 serves as a central hub for smart home automation, leveraging Amazon's Alexa voice assistant to control a wide array of compatible devices. The device supports a broad range of smart home brands and offers both voice and touch-screen control for managing connected devices. PCWorld's Ben Patterson noted that the device 'focuses on video chat participants' and integrates well with existing smart home ecosystems. The Echo Show 8 can display live video feeds from compatible doorbell and home security cameras such as the Ring Video Doorbell and Wyze Cam V3, making it a valuable addition to any smart home setup.
The smart home integration is extensive, with Alexa supporting a wide range of home automation devices, covering most major brands. Users can control lights, thermostats, locks, and other smart home devices through voice commands or the touch screen. The device also supports a variety of third-party Alexa skills, expanding its functionality beyond basic smart home controls. According to PCMag's Andrew Gebhart, the Echo Show 8 is 'packed with Alexa+ power,' indicating that it's well-suited for users who want a comprehensive smart home control center, though it's not the most advanced smart display on the market.
Real-World Performance
In real-world usage, the Echo Show 8 delivers consistent performance for its intended purpose as a smart display and communication device. PCMag's Will Greenwald noted that the device's hardware, while not dramatically different from the first generation, is sufficient for everyday tasks. The MediaTek MT8183 processor provides adequate performance for voice commands, smart home automation, and media streaming. The device responds quickly to voice commands, and the touch screen is responsive, making it easy to navigate through menus and control connected devices.
The Echo Show 8's performance is particularly notable in video calls, where the upgraded camera provides clear and focused video quality. The audio system is also effective for voice communication, with clear sound quality during video calls. However, the device's performance is limited by its reliance on the Alexa ecosystem, and users who prefer other voice assistants may find it less appealing. The device's performance in handling multiple tasks simultaneously is adequate, but it may struggle with more demanding applications or multitasking scenarios.
Where It Falls Short
Despite its strengths, the Echo Show 8 (2nd Gen) has notable shortcomings that may deter some users. CNET's reviewer specifically criticized the device for being 'pushy' with Alexa, suggesting that the assistant's behavior can be intrusive or overly aggressive in certain situations. This issue is particularly relevant for users who prefer a more subtle or hands-off approach to smart home assistants. Additionally, the device lacks a privacy shutter, which is a significant omission for privacy-conscious users, as noted by multiple reviewers including PCWorld's Ben Patterson.
Another limitation is the absence of motorized tracking in the camera, which is present in higher-end models like the Echo Show 10. While the 13MP camera with auto-framing is an improvement, it doesn't provide the same level of flexibility as a motorized tracking camera. The device's performance is also limited by its reliance on Amazon's ecosystem, which may not appeal to users who prefer more open or interoperable systems. The lack of significant hardware upgrades beyond the camera in the second-generation model means that users who expect major improvements may be disappointed.
Who It's Best For
The Amazon Echo Show 8 (2nd Gen) is ideal for users who are already invested in the Amazon ecosystem and want a smart display that offers a good balance of features, performance, and price. It's particularly well-suited for households that rely heavily on video communication, as the upgraded camera provides significantly better video quality for calls. PCWorld's Ben Patterson recommends it for those 'who've settled on the Alexa ecosystem,' emphasizing that the device is 'the smart display to get' for users who prefer Amazon's voice assistant.
The device is also a strong choice for users who value smart home integration and want a central hub for controlling connected devices. Its ability to display live video feeds from compatible security cameras and its support for a wide range of third-party Alexa skills make it a versatile addition to any smart home. However, users who prioritize privacy features or prefer non-Amazon ecosystems should look elsewhere, as the device lacks a privacy shutter and is heavily dependent on Amazon's services. The Echo Show 8 is best suited for those who want a reliable, well-integrated smart display without the premium price tag of higher-end models.
Value at This Price
At $129.99, the Echo Show 8 (2nd Gen) offers excellent value for money, particularly when compared to competing smart displays. PCMag's Will Greenwald notes that the device provides 'just the right balance of price, performance, and size,' making it a good value in the smart display market. The price point is competitive with other mid-range smart displays, and the device's features, including the upgraded camera and smart home integration, justify the cost for most users.
The device's value is further enhanced by its ability to serve multiple functions, from smart home control to video communication and entertainment. While it doesn't offer the most advanced features or the highest-end performance, it provides a solid, well-rounded experience that's suitable for most households. The lack of significant hardware upgrades beyond the camera in the second-generation model means that users who expect major improvements may find the price less justifiable, but for those seeking a reliable smart display at a reasonable price, the Echo Show 8 remains a strong contender.
Strengths
- +8-inch LCD screen with 1280x800 resolution provides clear visuals for videos and tutorials
- +Improved audio quality makes it suitable for both music and voice commands
- +Easy setup process that doesn't require a phone nearby
- +Good screen size for kitchen countertops, ideal for cooking tutorials and media viewing from 5-6 feet away
Watch-outs
- −Excessive cardboard packaging waste
- −Subtitle readability is poor on the screen
How it compares
The Echo Show 8 (2nd Gen) stands out for its kitchen-friendly 8-inch screen and simple setup process, unlike the Echo Show 5 (3rd Gen) which focuses on compact design and faster processor. While it's more affordable than the Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) with its spheroid design and spatial audio, it lacks the advanced smart home hub capabilities and privacy features found in the newer models.
Who this is for
At a glance: kitchen-focused users seeking affordable smart display.
Why you’d buy the Amazon Echo Show 8 (2nd Gen)
- 8-inch LCD screen with 1280x800 resolution provides clear visuals for videos and tutorials.
- Improved audio quality makes it suitable for both music and voice commands.
- Easy setup process that doesn't require a phone nearby.
Why you’d skip it
- Excessive cardboard packaging waste.
- Subtitle readability is poor on the screen.
Rating sources
Our 4.1 score is the average of these published ratings. More about methodology.
