Head-to-head · Best Roof Cargo Boxes

Thule Motion 3 XL Low vs Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

The short answer

Thule Motion 3 XL Low comes out ahead by a narrow margin (4.8 vs 4.6). The gap is mostly about family road trippers wanting flagship-tier cargo box — read the strengths below before deciding.

Higher ratedRanked #1 in Best Roof Cargo Boxes

Thule Motion 3 XL Low

4.8

$900

The Motion 3 XL Low is the best-overall pick — Thule's flagship combines quality, features, and ease.

Strengths

— Best all-around quality + features + ease of use
— Low-profile design reduces wind noise
— SwingRight dual-side opening

Watch-outs

— Premium pricing
— Heavier than aluminum boxes
— Requires roof rack base

$900 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Ranked #5 in Best Roof Cargo Boxes

Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite

4.6

$599

The SkyBox Carbonite is the budget Yakima pick — older Yakima cargo box at $599.

Strengths

— Textured Carbonite finish hides scratches
— Mid-tier Yakima at value price
— 16 cu ft capacity

Watch-outs

— Older Carbonite vs newer NX line
— Lower capacity than XL
— Texture marks differently than smooth finish

$599 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

How they stack up

Thule Motion 3 XL Low

Best overall. Low-profile. Lifetime warranty.

Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite

Budget Yakima. Carbonite texture. Lower capacity.

Specs side-by-side

Spec	Thule Motion 3 XL Low	Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite
Capacity	XL	16 cu ft
Profile	Low	—
Opening	SwingRight dual	—
Brand	Thule	Yakima
Finish	—	Carbonite texture
Tier	—	Budget

← See the full ranking of best roof cargo boxes