Verdict
Head-to-head · Best Smart Exercise Bikes

Peloton Cross Training Bike+ vs Schwinn IC4

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

Verdict is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you click through and buy, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our ratings are sourced from independent publications, not sponsors.
The short answer

Peloton Cross Training Bike+ comes out ahead by a clear margin (4.6 vs 4.3). Peloton Cross Training Bike+ is best for: Households that will use guided strength classes as much as cycling classes and accept a required monthly membership. Read the strengths below before deciding.

Peloton Cross Training Bike+
Higher ratedRanked #1 in Best Smart Exercise Bikes
Peloton Cross Training Bike+
4 sources$2,695as of Oct 10

The Peloton Cross Training Bike+ is the 2025 replacement for the original Bike+, adding an AI movement-tracking camera, voice control, a clip-on fan, a phone tray and a wider saddle to the 23.8-inch swivel screen and automatic resistance the older model already had. PCMag gave it an Editors' Choice after eight weeks, finding the rep counting accurate for the most part but the strength tracking limited to light, medium and heavy dumbbell settings. Engadget, after roughly four months, said the camera's guidance rarely made mistakes but noted it does not extend to yoga or pilates. Steady Athlete reported a screen wobble that worsens in standing sprints and a pedal squeak within the first month. The bike costs $2,695 and needs the $49.99-a-month All-Access membership for classes.

Strengths
  • — Movement-tracking camera counts reps and gives form corrections in strength classes; PCMag found it very rarely misses actual reps.
  • — Auto-Resistance adjusts to the instructor's cues; PCMag reports it changes right in time with each cue.
  • — 23.8-inch Full HD screen rotates a full 360 degrees and tilts for floor workouts, per PCMag.
Watch-outs
  • — $2,695 plus a $49.99 monthly All-Access membership; without it the bike only works in Just Ride mode, per PCMag.
  • — Steady Athlete reported screen wobble that gets worse during standing sprints, and that Peloton's tightening fix did not help.
  • — Strength tracking only knows light, medium and heavy dumbbells; PCMag could not edit the tracked weight to an exact value afterward.
Schwinn IC4
Ranked #3 in Best Smart Exercise Bikes
Schwinn IC4
3 sources$799as of Oct 10

The Schwinn IC4 delivers a smooth and quiet ride through its 40 lb flywheel and magnetic resistance system, which Garage Gym Reviews highlighted as high-performing for the price. Reviewed found significant value in the package, noting that it includes three-pound dumbbells and a Bluetooth heart rate monitor—accessories often sold separately by competitors. The bike’s open architecture allows seamless pairing with third-party apps like Peloton and Zwift via stable Bluetooth connectivity, though Outdoorgearlab cited inaccurate speed and distance readings on the onboard console as a drawback. While the dual-sided pedals accommodate both cleats and sneakers, the narrow and hard stock seat is frequently criticized for discomfort during longer sessions. This model fits users seeking app-based variety without proprietary subscriptions, but those prioritizing precise data tracking or immediate saddle comfort should look elsewhere.

Strengths
  • — Includes a Bluetooth-enabled heart rate monitor and pair of three-pound dumbbells, adding value not typically found at this price point.
  • — Features a 40 lb weighted flywheel with 100 levels of magnetic resistance for a smooth, quiet ride that requires little maintenance.
  • — Compatible with popular third-party fitness apps like Peloton, Zwift, and Explore the World via Bluetooth connectivity.
Watch-outs
  • — The included seat is frequently described as narrow and hard, often requiring users to purchase an aftermarket replacement for comfort.
  • — Inaccurate speed and distance readings

How they stack up

Peloton Cross Training Bike+

The Peloton Cross Training Bike+ and the NordicTrack X24 Bike are the two bikes on this page with a built-in class touchscreen, 23.8 inches on the Peloton and 24 inches on the X24; the Peloton entry also lists Auto-Resistance across 100 levels against the X24's 24 levels. The Schwinn IC4 has a backlit LCD console and relies on a separate phone or tablet for apps, and the Yosuda Indoor Cycling Bike has a basic LCD monitor with no connectivity. At $2,695 it costs more than three times the $799 Schwinn IC4 and more than the $1,999.99 X24. Its 297 lb rider limit is below the 350 lbs the X24 supports.

Schwinn IC4

The Schwinn IC4 stands out from the Peloton Cross Training Bike+ by offering open architecture compatibility with third-party apps like Zwift without a mandatory subscription, making it more flexible for data-driven cyclists. It also includes accessories such as dumbbells and a heart rate monitor, providing greater immediate value than the Yosuda Indoor Cycling Bike, which lacks connectivity features entirely.

Specs side-by-side

SpecPeloton Cross Training Bike+Schwinn IC4
Screen Size23.8-inch Full HD touchscreen, rotates 360° and tiltsBacklit LCD metric console
Resistance Levels0–100 with Auto-Resistance100 levels magnetic
Max Rider Weight297 lbs330 lbs
Rider Height4'11" to 6'5"—
Dimensions54" L x 22" W x 60" H48.75" L x 21.25" W x 52" H
ConnectivityBluetooth 5.2, Wi-FiBluetooth
PedalsDelta-compatible clip-in—
MembershipAll-Access, $49.99 per month (required for classes)—
Flywheel Weight—40 lbs
Product Weight—113.6 lbs
Resistance Type—smooth, magnetic resistance
← See the full ranking of best smart exercise bikes