Verdict
Head-to-head · Best Carbon Monoxide Detectors

First Alert SC5 Battery Smart Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Alarm vs Kidde Battery-Operated Carbon Monoxide Alarm

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

Verdict is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you click through and buy, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our ratings are sourced from independent publications, not sponsors.
The short answer

First Alert SC5 Battery Smart Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Alarm comes out ahead by a narrow margin (4.2 vs 4.0). First Alert SC5 Battery Smart Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Alarm is best for: google home households who want smoke and co alerts on their phone without wiring. Read the strengths below before deciding.

First Alert SC5 Battery Smart Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Alarm
Higher ratedRanked #3 in Best Carbon Monoxide Detectors
First Alert SC5 Battery Smart Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Alarm
1 source$125as of Oct 17

The First Alert SC5 is a battery-powered combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarm, measuring 5.75 x 5.75 x 1.6 inches, with an electrochemical CO sensor, a photoelectric smoke sensor and Google Home connectivity. CNET named it the best overall carbon monoxide detector in its lab-tested roundup, citing accurate sensors, phone alerts through Google Home and voice alerts that state what the alarm is sensing. Bob Vila rated it 4.5/5, reporting a three-minute setup with preinstalled batteries and a large centre button that silences cooking false alarms. It suits Google Home households that want smoke and CO coverage in places without wiring; homes where codes require hardwired alarms, or buyers fitting many rooms on a tight budget, should look elsewhere.

Strengths
  • — Detects smoke and carbon monoxide in one unit, with voice alerts that say which hazard it senses
  • — Links to the Google Home app via Nest Protect integration for phone alerts away from home
  • — CNET named it best overall CO detector after lab tests of its sensors
Watch-outs
  • — Battery-only power may not satisfy building codes that require a wired alarm
  • — Costs far more than standard alarms, which adds up when equipping a whole house
Kidde Battery-Operated Carbon Monoxide Alarm
Ranked #4 in Best Carbon Monoxide Detectors
Kidde Battery-Operated Carbon Monoxide Alarm
2 sourcesall derived$25.99as of Oct 2

The Kidde Battery-Operated Carbon Monoxide Alarm offers a 10-year service life with end-of-life beeping. The unit includes a low battery alarm and green operate light. Reviewers noted it's simple to use and reliable for family safety. This alarm is ideal for households seeking a simple battery-powered CO detector.

Strengths
  • — Battery-operated with 10-year service life and end-of-life beep indicator
  • — LED status lights plus a Test/Reset button that also silences the alarm
  • — Includes mounting bracket and batteries for easy installation
Watch-outs
  • — Potential for nuisance or false alarms

Derived means the reviewer published no score, so one was inferred from their written verdict. Everything else is a number the publisher printed. How we rank.

How they stack up

First Alert SC5 Battery Smart Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Alarm

Like the Kidde Smart Smoke + Carbon Monoxide Alarm and the X-Sense SC07-WX, the SC5 combines smoke and CO detection with app alerts, but it runs on batteries and works through Google Home. At around $125 it costs more than a single-purpose unit such as the Kidde Battery-Operated Carbon Monoxide Alarm, which covers carbon monoxide only.

Kidde Battery-Operated Carbon Monoxide Alarm

The Kidde Battery-Operated Carbon Monoxide Alarm detects carbon monoxide only, where the Kidde Smart Smoke + Carbon Monoxide Alarm and the Siterwell Wireless Interconnected Smoke & CO Alarm cover both smoke and CO. It runs on 3 AA batteries, against the Siterwell's built-in 10-year lithium battery and the Kidde Smart's hardwired power, and it costs less than both.

Specs side-by-side

SpecFirst Alert SC5 Battery Smart Smoke & Carbon Monoxide AlarmKidde Battery-Operated Carbon Monoxide Alarm
Power SourceBattery3 AA batteries (included)
Dimensions5.75 x 5.75 x 1.6 in1.5"D x 4.5"W x 2.75"H
Weight16 oz—
CO SensorElectrochemical—
Smoke SensorPhotoelectric—
AlertsSiren, voice, app—
Smart PlatformGoogle Home—
Battery Life—10 years
Installation—Wall bracket included
Detection Type—Carbon monoxide
Alarm Volume—85 decibels
Sensor Type—Electrochemical
Alert Type—Loud alarm with flashing light
← See the full ranking of best carbon monoxide detectors