Head-to-head · Best Fly Fishing Rods Under $300

Echo Carbon XL Fly Rods & Outfits vs Redington Vice

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

Verdict is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you click through and buy, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our ratings are sourced from independent publications, not sponsors.

The short answer

Echo Carbon XL Fly Rods & Outfits comes out ahead by a narrow margin (4.7 vs 4.5). Echo Carbon XL Fly Rods & Outfits is best for: versatile trout anglers. Read the strengths below before deciding.

Higher ratedRanked #1 in Best Fly Fishing Rods Under $300

Echo Carbon XL Fly Rods & Outfits

4.7

1 source$199.99as of Oct 11

The Echo Carbon XL 9-foot 5-weight fly rod delivers a sweet, harmonious casting experience that connects the angler's arm, hand, rod, and fly line in perfect synergy. Reviewers praised its medium-faster action, which allows it to handle both delicate dries and larger nymph droppers with ease. The rod's lightweight carbon fiber construction and single foot guides contribute to its excellent casting feel, though some users noted an initial adjustment period due to its slightly back-positioned grip. While it's versatile for most trout fishing applications, it's not specifically recommended for beginners venturing into euro nymphing without mentorship.

Strengths

— 9-foot 5-weight rod designed for versatility in trout fishing
— Medium-faster action that loads easily yet responds with crispness
— Lightweight carbon fiber construction with single foot guides

Watch-outs

— Grip sits slightly far back, making the rod feel awkward until you adjust

$199.99 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Ranked #4 in Best Fly Fishing Rods Under $300

Redington Vice

4.5

1 sourceall derived$279.99as of Oct 14

A fast-action, four-piece carbon fiber rod that Redington sells at $279.99. Hatch Magazine was hard-pressed to find fault with it after using the 9-weight on Louisiana redfish, reporting tight loops, accurate casts at 30 to 60 feet and performance that held up even with a poorly matched line. The reviewer's one quibble is its weight.

Strengths

— Threw tight loops when pushed and softer open loops at short range, per Hatch Magazine
— Accurate at 30 feet and in, with 50 feet reachable on one false cast in the reviewer's practice
— Shot spoon flies and heavy shrimp patterns into gusts with little problem

Watch-outs

— Not as light as more expensive fast-action rods; Hatch Magazine describes a beefy feel
— Hatch Magazine's review covers the 9-weight only, so its findings may not carry over to the trout weights

$279.99 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Derived means the reviewer published no score, so one was inferred from their written verdict. Everything else is a number the publisher printed. How we rank.

How they stack up

Echo Carbon XL Fly Rods & Outfits

The Echo Carbon XL Fly Rods & Outfits is a 9-foot 5-weight with a medium-faster action, where the Redington Classic Trout is a medium-action rod and the Redington Vice a fast-action one. It costs less than the Orvis Clearwater Fly Rods and the Redington Vice. Its grip sits slightly far back, which can feel awkward until the angler adjusts.

Redington Vice

The Vice is the fast-action choice on this page; the Redington Classic Trout is a medium-action rod and the Orvis Clearwater medium-fast. At $279.99 it costs more than the Classic Trout and Echo Carbon XL (both $199.99) and less than the Orvis Clearwater ($298).

Specs side-by-side

Spec	Echo Carbon XL Fly Rods & Outfits	Redington Vice
Length	9 feet	9 ft (990-4, the size Hatch Magazine reviewed)
Action	Medium-faster	Fast
Material	Carbon fiber	Multi-modulus carbon fiber
Grip	cork	—
Guides	Single foot	Black anodized snake guides
Sections	4 piece	4-piece
Line Weight	—	9

← See the full ranking of best fly fishing rods under $300