Head-to-head · Best Cold Brew Coffee Makers

County Line Kitchen Cold Brew Mason Jar Coffee Maker vs Toddy Cold Brew Coffee Maker System

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

The short answer

County Line Kitchen Cold Brew Mason Jar Coffee Maker comes out ahead by a clear margin (4.4 vs 3.8). The gap is mostly about budget-conscious beginners — read the strengths below before deciding.

Higher ratedRanked #4 in Best Cold Brew Coffee Makers

County Line Kitchen Cold Brew Mason Jar Coffee Maker

4.4

$24.99as of Jun 29

The County Line Kitchen Cold Brew Coffee Maker is a popular mason jar brewer that's praised for its versatility and ease of use. The Kitchn called it 'adorable' and noted its dishwasher-safe design, while Shouldit reviewers found it practical but recommended longer brewing times and additional decanting due to sediment issues. The product comes in 1-quart and 2-quart sizes with color options and includes a stainless steel mesh filter. It's ideal for those wanting a simple, functional cold brew solution but may not satisfy users seeking complex flavor profiles.

Strengths

— Versatile product that can be used for both coffee and iced tea
— Dishwasher-safe design with easy cleanup
— Airtight silicone gasket prevents leaks

Watch-outs

— Filter is not very effective at removing sediment
— Brew strength is average and lacks complexity

$24.99 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Ranked #7 in Best Cold Brew Coffee Makers

Toddy Cold Brew Coffee Maker System

3.8

$44.95as of Jun 29

The Toddy Cold Brew Coffee Maker System offers a streamlined approach to home cold brewing with its reliable reusable filter system that prevents mess and spilling. Reviewers praise its ease of use and ability to produce smooth, flavorful cold brew with minimal sediment. Home Grounds reviewer Julia Bobak noted its practical design and dual-filtration options, while Low-Key Coffee Snobs user David Hayes highlighted its effectiveness for regular household use. However, some reviewers noted the messy stopper removal process and relatively high cost compared to DIY alternatives. This system suits coffee enthusiasts seeking convenience and consistent results over traditional methods.

Strengths

— Reliable reusable filter system that eliminates mess and spilling
— Easy to assemble and use with clear brewing instructions
— Large capacity of up to 45 ounces for concentrate brewing

Watch-outs

— Removing the stopper can be messy and prone to spills
— Relatively expensive compared to basic DIY methods
— Filter replacement components may need periodic replacement

$44.95 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

How they stack up

County Line Kitchen Cold Brew Mason Jar Coffee Maker

The County Line Kitchen's mason jar design is dishwasher-safe and leak-proof, a feature not found in the more complex OXO or Toddy systems. It's also more affordable than the Ovalware pitcher and offers versatility for both coffee and iced tea, unlike the more specialized KitchenAid or Hario models. However, it's less effective at removing sediment compared to the Toddy or OXO systems, and it lacks the durability and precision of the stainless steel components found in the KitchenAid or Ovalware models.

Toddy Cold Brew Coffee Maker System

The Toddy system provides a reliable reusable filter that prevents mess and spilling, a feature not found in the OXO or Hario models. It's more durable than the glass-based Ovalware pitcher and offers a larger 45-ounce capacity, surpassing the KitchenAid 28-oz model. However, unlike the KitchenAid 38-oz, it lacks a built-in tap for easy dispensing and doesn't offer the airtight seal for freshness that the Ovalware pitcher provides.

Specs side-by-side

Spec	County Line Kitchen Cold Brew Mason Jar Coffee Maker	Toddy Cold Brew Coffee Maker System
Capacity	1 quart	45 oz concentrate
Filter Type	Stainless steel mesh	Cloth and paper options
Material	Glass	Plastic brewing chamber, glass carafe
Brew Time	12+ hours	8-24 hours
Dispenser	Built-in stainless steel tap	Built-in stainless steel tap
Lid Type	Airtight silicone gasket	Airtight silicone gasket
Weight	17.0 oz	Approx. 2.5 lbs

← See the full ranking of best cold brew coffee makers