Verdict
Head-to-head · Best Golf Balls

Callaway Supersoft vs TaylorMade Tour Response

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

Verdict is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you click through and buy, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our ratings are sourced from independent publications, not sponsors.
The short answer

TaylorMade Tour Response comes out ahead by a narrow margin (4.5 vs 4.4). TaylorMade Tour Response is best for: moderate swingers wanting premium control. Read the strengths below before deciding.

Callaway Supersoft
Ranked #7 in Best Golf Balls
Callaway Supersoft
1 source$26.97as of Oct 31

The Callaway Supersoft utilizes a 38-compression core and Hex Aerodynamics dimple pattern to deliver exceptional softness off the putter and wedge while promoting straighter ball flight through low driver spin. Breakingeighty notes this construction creates a tactile experience closer to premium tour balls, while Golfspan explains that reduced drag enhances carry distance for players with swing speeds below 85 mph. However, Seniorgolfsource explicitly categorizes it as a distance ball offering limited greenside spin, meaning the ionomer cover cannot match the stopping power of urethane-covered options on approach shots. This makes the Supersoft an ideal choice for high handicappers seeking forgiveness and length, whereas advanced players requiring precise green-side control should look elsewhere.

Strengths
  • — Ultra-low compression core rated at 38 provides an exceptionally soft feel off the putter and wedge.
  • — Low driver spin rate promotes a straighter ball flight to help reduce slices for high handicappers.
  • — Hex Aerodynamics dimple pattern reduces drag to enhance lift, carry distance, and hang time.
Watch-outs
  • — Minimal greenside spin compared to urethane-covered tour balls limits stopping power on approach shots.
  • — Shallow dimple depth can make the ball appear smooth, which some golfers find off-putting at address.
TaylorMade Tour Response
Higher ratedRanked #2 in Best Golf Balls
TaylorMade Tour Response
2 sources$34.99as of Oct 31

The TaylorMade Tour Response delivers tour-level greenside spin and a soft feel around 70 compression, making it ideal for golfers with driver swing speeds between 85 and 110 mph. Mygolfspy found that the ball retains iron speed effectively, while Golferhive reported genuine checking power from its 100% cast urethane cover. However, the soft core over-compresses for players swinging faster than 105 mph, resulting in lost distance, and the cover durability falls short of harder ionomer-covered balls. This model fits moderate swing speed players seeking premium performance without a high price tag, while fast swingers should look elsewhere.

Strengths
  • — 100% cast urethane cover provides tour-level greenside spin and checking power.
  • — Soft feel around 70 compression maximizes ball speed for moderate swing speeds (85-110 mph).
  • — Speed Wrapped Core and HFM Mantle maintain energy transfer without sacrificing softness.
Watch-outs
  • — Over-compresses for players with driver swing speeds exceeding 105 mph, losing distance.
  • — Cover durability falls short of harder ionomer-covered distance balls.

How they stack up

Callaway Supersoft

The Callaway Supersoft features an ultra-low 38 compression core, making it significantly softer than the Srixon Soft Feel Golf Balls which use a firmer 60-compression FastLayer core. While both are two-piece ionomer balls, the Supersoft prioritizes straight ball flight through low driver spin, unlike the TaylorMade Noodle Long and Soft which emphasizes high launch trajectory for carry distance.

TaylorMade Tour Response

The TaylorMade Tour Response provides tour-level greenside spin with its cast urethane cover, a significant advantage over the ionomer-covered Callaway Supersoft which limits stopping power.

Specs side-by-side

SpecCallaway SupersoftTaylorMade Tour Response
ConstructionTwo-piece3-piece
Cover MaterialIonomer100% Cast Urethane
Compression38~70
Dimple PatternHex AerodynamicsTour Flight Dimple Pattern
Price Per Dozen$25 or less$39.99
Core TechnologyHyperElastic SoftFast CoreSpeed Wrap Core
Target Swing Speedbelow 85mph with a driver85-110 mph
← See the full ranking of best golf balls