Head-to-head · Best All-in-One Printers Under $300

Brother MFC-J4355DW vs HP Envy 6555e

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

The short answer

Brother MFC-J4355DW comes out ahead by a narrow margin (4.7 vs 4.5). The gap is mostly about home + small office users printing homework, tax forms, and occasional documents — read the strengths below before deciding.

Higher ratedRanked #1 in Best All-in-One Printers Under $300

Brother MFC-J4355DW

4.7

$209

The MFC-J4355DW is the best-overall all-in-one under $300. Brother's INKvestment cartridges last roughly 6 months for a family printing homework and documents. Best for home + small office users who want low ongoing cost without paying for EcoTank.

Strengths

— INKvestment Tank system — high-yield cartridges lasted ~1,200 pages in editorial testing
— Print + scan + copy + fax with 2.7" color touchscreen
— Wireless + USB + Ethernet connectivity

Watch-outs

— INKvestment isn't an actual EcoTank-style refill system — it's cartridge-based
— Print speed (13 ppm) trails business laser printers
— Photo quality good but trails dedicated photo printers

$209 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Ranked #2 in Best All-in-One Printers Under $300

HP Envy 6555e

4.5

$150

The Envy 6555e is the simplicity pick. HP Smart App + Instant Ink trial is the most beginner-friendly setup in this lineup. Trade-off is the Instant Ink subscription model that activates after the trial.

Strengths

— HP+ Smart App integration for mobile printing
— Quiet mode for shared/home offices
— 6 months Instant Ink trial — free during evaluation

Watch-outs

— Instant Ink subscription model after trial — ongoing cost vs Brother cartridges
— Slower than Brother MFC-J4355DW (10 ppm)
— HP+ ties printer to HP-brand ink (third-party cartridges restricted)

$150 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

How they stack up

Brother MFC-J4355DW

Best balance of features + ink longevity. More features than HP Envy 6555e. Cheaper than Epson EcoTank picks.

HP Envy 6555e

Cheapest HP pick. Subscription ink (Instant Ink) vs Brother cartridges. HP Smart App easier than Brother iPrint.

Specs side-by-side

Spec	Brother MFC-J4355DW	HP Envy 6555e
Print Speed	13 ppm	10 ppm
Display	2.7" color touchscreen	2.4" LCD
Connectivity	Wi-Fi, USB, Ethernet	Wi-Fi, USB
Duplex	Auto	—
Ink	INKvestment cartridges	—
Ink Model	—	Instant Ink subscription

← See the full ranking of best all-in-one printers under $300