Head-to-head · Best Dog Crates

Amazon Basics Portable, Collapsible Metal Wire Dog Crate with Removable Tray, Do vs MidWest Homes for Pets 30-Inch iCrate for Medium Breeds, 21-40 lbs, Double Door

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

The short answer

Amazon Basics Portable, Collapsible Metal Wire Dog Crate with Removable Tray, Do comes out ahead by a clear margin (4.5 vs 3.6). The gap is mostly about budget-conscious buyers with small, non-aggressive dogs — read the strengths below before deciding.

Higher ratedRanked #2 in Best Dog Crates

Amazon Basics Portable, Collapsible Metal Wire Dog Crate with Removable Tray, Do

4.5

$49.99as of Jul 8

The Amazon Basics Foldable Metal Wire Dog Crate offers a budget-friendly solution for small dogs and puppies. Reviewers praised its quick setup, portability, and removable tray for easy cleaning. The divider panel helps with potty training, and the single-door design provides secure containment. However, some users noted the wire frame isn't chew-proof and the plastic tray can become brittle with heavy use. This crate is best suited for small breeds under 18 lbs but may not meet the needs of larger or destructive chewers.

Strengths

— Easy to set up and store with no tools required
— Portable design folds flat with a handle for transport
— Includes divider panel for puppy training adjustments

Watch-outs

— Not chew-proof; wire frame is vulnerable to aggressive chewers
— Plastic tray may crack under heavy use

$49.99 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Ranked #7 in Best Dog Crates

MidWest Homes for Pets 30-Inch iCrate for Medium Breeds, 21-40 lbs, Double Door

3.6

$49.29as of Jul 8

The MidWest Homes for Pets iCrate Double Door crate is praised for its ease of assembly, portability, and sturdy construction suitable for medium breeds (21-40 lbs). Reviewers highlighted the double-door design for flexible placement, the included divider panel for training, and the leak-proof pan for housebreaking. Some users noted minor manufacturing defects like bent metal parts and slight door sagging, but overall it's considered a solid value for small to medium dogs. It's ideal for pet parents seeking a durable, foldable crate for indoor use and travel.

Strengths

— Double doors allow flexible placement in tight spaces
— Includes divider panel to adjust living space for growing puppies
— Leak-proof plastic pan makes cleaning easy during housebreaking

Watch-outs

— Some users reported bent metal parts from manufacturing or transit
— Door sags slightly on some units, requiring upward pull to close

$49.29 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

How they stack up

Amazon Basics Portable, Collapsible Metal Wire Dog Crate with Removable Tray, Do

The Amazon Basics crate is the most budget-friendly option, but it's not chew-proof like the Impact High Anxiety or Sweetcrispy models. Unlike the EliteField soft crate, it lacks a spacious interior and three doors, and unlike the MidWest Homes, it doesn't include a divider panel. It's a basic wire crate that's good for small dogs but not for aggressive chewers.

MidWest Homes for Pets 30-Inch iCrate for Medium Breeds, 21-40 lbs, Double Door

The MidWest Homes crate stands out for its included divider panel and leak-proof pan, features not found in the Amazon Basics or FDW models. However, it lacks the collapsible wheel design of the Diggs Revol and the airline compliance of the Petmate Vari. While it offers solid portability, it's less versatile than the Diggs Revol for travel and more basic than the Sweetcrispy for security.

Specs side-by-side

Spec	Amazon Basics Portable, Collapsible Metal Wire Dog Crate with Removable Tray, Do	MidWest Homes for Pets 30-Inch iCrate for Medium Breeds, 21-40 lbs, Double Door
Dimensions	22.0"L x 13.0"W x 16.0"H	30.67"L x 19.3"W x 21.46"H
Weight	9.88 pounds	21-40 lbs
Material	Metal wire	Wire frame
Door Type	single-door	Double Door style
Features	Removable tray, divider panel, single door	Leak-proof pan, divider panel, rubber feet
Usage	indoor use	—

← See the full ranking of best dog crates